The pair of metal ions that can give a spin only magnetic moment of 3.9 BM for the complex , is:
For an octahedral complex of the type we first note that each chloride ion is the counter-ion and water is the only ligand present. Water () is a weak‐field ligand, so the complex formed is expected to be high-spin in every case. Because there are two chloride ions outside the bracket, the metal must be in the oxidation state.
The spin-only magnetic moment is given by the well-known formula
where is the number of unpaired electrons in the d-orbitals of the metal ion.
The question states that the observed moment is . We equate this to the formula to find the corresponding :
Squaring both sides,
Trial with small integer values shows
The calculated value matches the required very well, so we need exactly unpaired electrons.
Now we inspect each metal ion in the state, remembering that the complex is high-spin.
1.
Atomic number of V = 23. Neutral configuration: .
Removing two electrons (first from 4s, then 3d) gives .
High-spin means one electron in each of the three t2g orbitals and none in eg, so
2.
Atomic number of Co = 27. Neutral configuration: .
After losing two 4s electrons: .
In a high-spin octahedral field the filling is . Let us count the unpaired electrons explicitly:
• For the first three electrons occupy the three orbitals singly (3 unpaired).
The fourth pairs with one of them (now 2 unpaired).
The fifth pairs with another (now 1 unpaired).
• The next two electrons go into the two eg orbitals singly, adding 2 more unpaired.
Total .
Again
3.
high-spin gives with unpaired, leading to , which is too high.
4.
high-spin has unpaired, again too high.
5.
high-spin has unpaired, giving , also too high.
Thus the only ions that individually provide exactly three unpaired electrons, and therefore a spin-only moment of about , are and . These appear together in option D.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.