CFSE for Strong Field Complexes
Phenanthroline (phen) is a strong field bidentate ligand. In an octahedral crystal field, it forces electrons to pair up in the lower-energy t2g orbitals before filling the higher-energy eg orbitals (low-spin complexes). The CFSE formula for an octahedral complex (ignoring pairing energy) is:
CFSE=[(−0.4×nt2g)+(0.6×neg)]Δo
Step-by-Step Analysis of Each Complex Ion:
-
1. [Ni(phen)3]2+→[Ni(phen)3]3+
- Ni2+ (s0d8) configuration: t2g6eg2⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+2(0.6)]Δo=−1.2Δo
- Ni3+ (s0d7) configuration: t2g6eg1⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+1(0.6)]Δo=−1.8Δo
- Result: CFSE increases in magnitude (gains stabilization energy).
2. [Fe(phen)3]2+→[Fe(phen)3]3+
- Fe2+ is a d6 system. In a strong field, its configuration is t2g6eg0.
CFSE=[6×(−0.4)+0×0.6]Δo=−2.4Δo - Fe3+ is a d5 system. In a strong field, its configuration is t2g5eg0.
CFSE=[5×(−0.4)+0×0.6]Δo=−2.0Δo - Result: The CFSE magnitude drops from −2.4Δo to −2.0Δo (it loses stabilization energy).
-
3. [Co(phen)3]2+→[Co(phen)3]3+
- Co2+ (s0d7) configuration: t2g6eg1⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+1(0.6)]Δo=−1.8Δo
- Co3+ (s0d6) configuration: t2g6eg0⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+0(0.6)]Δo=−2.4Δo
- Result: CFSE increases in magnitude (gains stabilization energy).
-
4. [Zn(phen)3]2+→[Zn(phen)3]3+
- Zn2+ (s0d10) configuration: t2g6eg4⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+4(0.6)]Δo=0Δo
- Zn3+ (s0d9) configuration: t2g6eg3⟹CFSE=[6(−0.4)+3(0.6)]Δo=−0.6Δo
- Result: CFSE increases in magnitude (gains stabilization energy).
Conclusion:
Only the iron complex undergoes a decrease in its crystal field stabilization energy upon oxidation from +2 to +3.
Answer: Option B — [Fe(phen)₃]²⁺