Which of the following complex ions has electrons that are symmetrically filled in both and orbitals?
To determine which complex ion has electrons symmetrically filled in both and orbitals, we need to analyze the electron configuration of each complex. Symmetric filling means that within each set of orbitals ( or ), the electrons are distributed evenly—either all orbitals are half-filled (one electron per orbital) or fully filled (two electrons per orbital). This ensures a symmetric electron distribution.
We will evaluate each option by finding the oxidation state of the central metal ion, the number of d-electrons, and the spin state (high or low) based on the ligands. Then, we will distribute the electrons in the octahedral crystal field splitting diagram ( and orbitals) and check for symmetric filling.
Option A:
Ammonia () is a neutral ligand, so the charge comes from the metal ion. The complex has a +2 charge, so cobalt (Co) must be in the +2 oxidation state. Cobalt has an atomic number of 27, so has the electron configuration . Ammonia is a strong field ligand, so the complex is low spin. In a low spin octahedral complex, electrons fill the lower energy orbitals first. For :
So, . The set is fully filled (symmetric), but the set has one electron in one orbital and an empty orbital, which is asymmetric. Therefore, this complex does not have symmetric filling in both sets.
Option B:
Cyanide () has a -1 charge. The complex has a -4 charge, so manganese (Mn) must be in the +2 oxidation state (since gives ). Manganese has an atomic number of 25, so has the configuration . Cyanide is a strong field ligand, so the complex is low spin. For low spin :
The set has five electrons: two orbitals are fully filled (two electrons each), and one orbital has one electron. This is asymmetric because the orbitals have different occupancies. The set is empty (symmetric), but since is asymmetric, the complex does not have symmetric filling in both sets.
Option C:
Fluoride () has a -1 charge. The complex has a -3 charge, so cobalt (Co) must be in the +3 oxidation state (since gives ). Cobalt has an atomic number of 27, so has the configuration . Fluoride is a weak field ligand, so the complex is high spin. For high spin :
So, . The set is asymmetric (different occupancies), while the set is half-filled (symmetric). Since is asymmetric, the complex does not have symmetric filling in both sets.
Option D:
Fluoride () has a -1 charge. The complex has a -3 charge, so iron (Fe) must be in the +3 oxidation state (since gives ). Iron has an atomic number of 26, so has the configuration . Fluoride is a weak field ligand, so the complex is high spin. For high spin :
So, . Both sets are half-filled: has one electron per orbital (symmetric), and has one electron per orbital (symmetric). Therefore, this complex has symmetric filling in both sets.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.