A reaction of cobalt (III) chloride and ethylenediamine in a 1 : 2 mole ratio generates two isomeric products A (violet-coloured) and B (green-coloured). A can show optical activity, but, B is optically inactive. What type of isomers do A and B represent?
The metal salt given is cobalt(III) chloride, written as .
The ligand is ethylenediamine, commonly abbreviated as .
According to the statement, the mole ratio is , so we combine one mole of the metal salt with two moles of the bidentate ligand:
In the product ion , the cobalt(III) centre has six coordination sites.
We fill those six sites as follows: two sites are occupied by one ligand (because is bidentate), another two sites are occupied by the second ligand, and the remaining two sites are taken by two chloride ions bound directly to cobalt.
Thus the coordination sphere is octahedral:
Whenever an octahedral complex contains two identical bidentate ligands ( and ) and two identical monodentate ligands ( and ), two distinct spatial arrangements are possible:
1. Cis arrangement - the two chloride ligands occupy adjacent positions.
2. Trans arrangement - the two chloride ligands occupy positions opposite each other.
The cis form of lacks any plane of symmetry or centre of symmetry because the two bidentate ligands are twisted in such a way that the whole complex becomes chiral.
Therefore the cis isomer is optically active and can rotate the plane of polarised light.
The trans form has a plane of symmetry passing through the cobalt atom and between the two ligands; this destroys any chirality, rendering the complex optically inactive.
We are told that product A is violet and optically active, while product B is green and optically inactive.
Hence, A must be the cis isomer and B must be the trans isomer.
The cis-trans pair represents a difference in the spatial (geometric) positions of the ligands around the same central atom without altering the connectivity of ligands.
This type of relationship is called geometrical isomerism.
So, A and B are geometrical isomers of each other.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.