RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The total number of isomers for a square planar complex: [MCl(F)(NO2)(SCN)][MCl(F)(NO_2)(SCN)] is:

SOLUTION

We have the square-planar complex [ MCl(F)(NO2)(SCN) ] .[\,MCl(F)(NO_2)(SCN)\,]\,.

A square-planar species possesses four positions at the corners of a square. Each position is cis (adjacent) to the two neighbouring positions and trans (opposite) to the position across the square. Because free rotation of the whole molecule does not create a new isomer, the only stereochemical issue is which ligand is opposite (trans to) which other ligand.

First we find the geometrical (cis-trans) possibilities. For a formula of type MA B C DMA\,B\,C\,D with four different monodentate ligands the number of different trans pairs equals the number of ways of dividing the four ligands into two unordered pairs. The known combinatorial result is

Number of ways=4!2! 2! 2!=3.\text{Number of ways}=\frac{4!}{2!\,2!\,2!}=3.

Hence we can list the three distinct geometrical isomers as follows (showing only the two trans pairs each time):

1.  Cl ⁣− ⁣F,    NO2 ⁣− ⁣SCN2.  Cl ⁣− ⁣NO2,    F ⁣− ⁣SCN3.  Cl ⁣− ⁣SCN,    F ⁣− ⁣NO2\begin{aligned} &1.\; Cl\!-\!F,\;\; NO_2\!-\!SCN\\[2pt] &2.\; Cl\!-\!NO_2,\;\; F\!-\!SCN\\[2pt] &3.\; Cl\!-\!SCN,\;\; F\!-\!NO_2 \end{aligned}

So, three geometrical isomers exist.

Next we examine possible linkage isomerism. Both NO2−NO_2^{-} and SCN−SCN^{-} are ambidentate:

  • NO2−NO_2^{-} can bind through nitrogen to give a nitro ligand (−NO2)(-NO_2) or through oxygen to give a nitrito ligand (−ONO).(-ONO). Hence, NO2−NO_2^{-} offers 22 linkage modes.
  • SCN−SCN^{-} can bind through sulfur to give thiocyanato (−SCN)(-SCN) or through nitrogen to give isothiocyanato (−NCS).(-NCS). Hence, SCN−SCN^{-} also offers 22 linkage modes.

The chloride and fluoride ligands are not ambidentate, so no extra choices arise from them. Because the choice of donor atom for NO2−NO_2^{-} is independent of the choice for SCN−,SCN^{-}, the total multiplication factor due to linkage isomerism is

2×2=4.2 \times 2 = 4.

Now we combine the two kinds of isomerism. For each of the three geometrical arrangements we may realise the complex in four different linkage forms, giving

Total isomers=3×4=12.\text{Total isomers}=3 \times 4 = 12.

No optical isomerism occurs, because every square-planar complex is achiral (it lies in a plane and has an internal mirror plane).

So, the grand total of distinguishable isomers is 12.12.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice