RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The species that can have a trans-isomer is:
(en = ethane-1, 2-diamine, ox = oxalate)

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling the condition for the existence of cis‒trans (geometrical) isomerism. For a coordination compound to display a trans-isomer we must be able to place two identical ligands at 180° to each other. This is possible only

(i)\text{(i)} in an octahedral complex (coordination number 66), or (ii)\text{(ii)} in a square-planar complex (coordination number 44).

If all the positions are equivalent, as in a tetrahedral complex, geometrical isomerism does not arise.

Now we examine each option one by one.

Option A : [ Cr(en)2(ox) ]+[\,\text{Cr(en)}_2(\text{ox})\,]^+

Here en\text{en} is bidentate and occupies 22 sites, so 2(en)=42(\text{en}) = 4 sites. The oxalate ion (ox)2−\text{(ox)}^{2-} is also bidentate and occupies the remaining 22 sites. Hence coordination number =6=6 and the geometry is octahedral. However, all three ligands are bidentate; none of them is present as a pair of identical monodentate ligands. With three chelating ligands fixed in space, there is only one possible arrangement (apart from optical isomerism). Therefore no cis-trans pair can be formed.

Option B : [ Pt(en)Cl2 ][\,\text{Pt(en)Cl}_2\,]

Platinum(II) generally forms square-planar complexes. One en\text{en} ligand occupies two adjacent positions in the square plane. The remaining two positions are automatically filled by the two chloride ions, which lie opposite each other. Thus only one geometry exists; we cannot place the chlorides both adjacent and opposite, so cis-trans isomerism is absent.

Option C : [ Zn(en)Cl2 ][\,\text{Zn(en)Cl}_2\,]

Zinc(II) with two chlorides and one bidentate en\text{en} usually adopts a tetrahedral geometry (coordination number 44). All four corners of a tetrahedron are equivalent; hence no geometrical isomerism (and therefore no trans-form) is possible.

Option D : [ Pt(en)2Cl2 ]2+[\,\text{Pt(en)}_2\text{Cl}_2\,]^{2+}

Let us determine the coordination number and geometry.

Each en\text{en} ligand is bidentate: 2(en)×2=42(\text{en}) \times 2 = 4 sites. Two monodentate Cl−\text{Cl}^- ions occupy the remaining 22 sites, giving a total of 66 coordination positions. An Pt4+\text{Pt}^{4+} complex with coordination number 66 is octahedral.

In an octahedron containing two identical monodentate ligands (the two Cl−\text{Cl}^- ions) beside other ligands, we can arrange the two chlorides either

• adjacent, giving the cis-isomer, or • opposite each other, giving the trans-isomer.

Both arrangements are feasible because the two chlorides can be placed at 90° or 180° relative to each other without breaking the chelate rings formed by the en\text{en} ligands. Hence this complex definitely exhibits a trans-isomer.

Summarising our findings:

[ Cr(en)2(ox) ]+[\,\text{Cr(en)}_2(\text{ox})\,]^+ - no trans [ Pt(en)Cl2 ][\,\text{Pt(en)Cl}_2\,] - no trans [ Zn(en)Cl2 ][\,\text{Zn(en)Cl}_2\,] - no trans [ Pt(en)2Cl2 ]2+[\,\text{Pt(en)}_2\text{Cl}_2\,]^{2+} - has a trans-isomer

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice