RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The correct statement on the isomerism associated with the following complex ions.
(a) [Ni(H2O)5NH3]2+[Ni(H_2O)_5NH_3]^{2+}
(b) [Ni(H2O)4(NH3)2]2+[Ni(H_2O)_4(NH_3)_2]^{2+} and
(c) [Ni(H2O)3(NH3)3]2+[Ni(H_2O)_3(NH_3)_3]^{2+} is:

SOLUTION

First of all we recall that the nickel(II) ion, Ni2+Ni^{2+}, generally forms octahedral complexes. In an octahedral field there are six positions arranged at the corners of a regular octahedron round the metal. When the ligands are monodentate (here H2OH_2O and NH3NH_3), the type of isomerism that can appear depends only on how many ligands of each kind are present.

An octahedral complex [MA6][MA_6] containing one kind of ligand has only one possible arrangement, so no isomerism is possible. As soon as two kinds of ligands are present, we label the possible stoichiometries and examine them one by one.

We need two facts.

• Fact 1 - Geometrical (cis-trans / fac-mer) isomerism.
  • MA5BMA_5B has only one possible arrangement, so it cannot show geometrical isomerism.
  • MA4B2MA_4B_2 can have the two BB ligands opposite each other (trans) or adjacent (cis), so it does show geometrical isomerism.
  • MA3B3MA_3B_3 can exist as fac (three identical ligands occupy one triangular face) and mer (three identical ligands lie on a meridian), so it also does show geometrical isomerism.

• Fact 2 - Optical isomerism.
For octahedral complexes that contain only monodentate ligands, a necessary condition for optical activity is the absence of any plane of symmetry, centre of symmetry or improper rotation axis. The common simple formulas that satisfy this condition are the chelated types M(AA)3M(AA)_3, M(AA)2BCM(AA)_2BC, MABCDEFMABCDEF etc. Simple arrangements such as MA5BMA_5B, MA4B2MA_4B_2 and MA3B3MA_3B_3 constructed exclusively from monodentate ligands always possess at least one symmetry element, therefore they are optically inactive.

Armed with these two facts we analyse each complex.

(a) [Ni(H2O)5NH3]2+[Ni(H_2O)_5NH_3]^{2+}

We compare its formula with the general notation:

[Ni(H2O)5NH3]2+  ≡  MA5B[Ni(H_2O)_5NH_3]^{2+}\; \equiv\; MA_5B with A=H2OA = H_2O and B=NH3B = NH_3.

From Fact 1, the type MA5BMA_5B has only one possible spatial arrangement, hence no geometrical isomerism. From Fact 2, it is automatically optically inactive. Therefore complex (a) shows no isomerism at all.

(b) [Ni(H2O)4(NH3)2]2+[Ni(H_2O)_4(NH_3)_2]^{2+}

Its pattern fits

[Ni(H2O)4(NH3)2]2+  ≡  MA4B2[Ni(H_2O)_4(NH_3)_2]^{2+}\; \equiv\; MA_4B_2 with A=H2O,  B=NH3A = H_2O,\; B = NH_3.

For MA4B2MA_4B_2 the two BB ligands can be placed:

cis: ∠(B−Ni−B)=90∘\displaystyle \text{cis: } \angle(B{-}Ni{-}B)=90^{\circ}
trans: ∠(B−Ni−B)=180∘\displaystyle \text{trans: } \angle(B{-}Ni{-}B)=180^{\circ}

Thus complex (b) exists as a cis and a trans pair, giving geometrical isomerism.

The cis as well as the trans form possesses a plane of symmetry passing through the metal and bisecting the two BB ligands (in the cis form) or passing through both BB ligands themselves (in the trans form). Hence each form is superposable on its mirror image and cannot be optically active. So there is no optical isomerism for (b).

(c) [Ni(H2O)3(NH3)3]2+[Ni(H_2O)_3(NH_3)_3]^{2+}

This matches

[Ni(H2O)3(NH3)3]2+  ≡  MA3B3[Ni(H_2O)_3(NH_3)_3]^{2+}\; \equiv\; MA_3B_3 where again A=H2O,  B=NH3A = H_2O,\; B = NH_3.

For MA3B3MA_3B_3 two arrangements are possible:

1. fac (facial): the three AA ligands occupy one face of the octahedron; all three A−Ni−AA{-}Ni{-}A angles are 90∘90^{\circ}.
2. mer (meridional): two AA ligands are trans and the third is cis to both; the set of three AA ligands lies on a meridian.

Therefore complex (c) also exhibits geometrical isomerism (fac and mer). Each of these two arrangements contains at least one plane (or an improper axis) of symmetry, so by Fact 2 neither the fac nor the mer form is chiral. Hence no optical isomerism arises for (c).

We may now summarise the findings:

• (a) shows neither geometrical nor optical isomerism.
• (b) shows geometrical isomerism only.
• (c) shows geometrical isomerism only.

The pair of complexes that satisfy “show only geometrical isomerism” is therefore (b) and (c).

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice