RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides

The correct order of the solubility of alkaline-earth metal sulphates in water is:

SOLUTION

First, let us recall a key idea from general inorganic chemistry. When an ionic solid such as a sulphate M2+SO42−M^{2+}SO_4^{2-} (where M2+M^{2+} is an alkaline-earth metal ion) dissolves in water, two enthalpy terms dominate the energetics:

ΔHsolution  =  ΔHlattice  +  ΔHhydration\Delta H_{\text{solution}} \;=\; \Delta H_{\text{lattice}} \;+\; \Delta H_{\text{hydration}}

Here,

ΔHlattice\Delta H_{\text{lattice}} is the lattice enthalpy, the energy required to pull the M2+M^{2+} and SO42−SO_4^{2-} ions apart from the crystal, so it is always positive.

ΔHhydration\Delta H_{\text{hydration}} is the hydration enthalpy, the energy released when those free ions are surrounded by water molecules, so it is always negative.

An ionic salt will be readily soluble when the magnitude of the (negative) hydration enthalpy outweighs the (positive) lattice enthalpy, making the overall ΔHsolution\Delta H_{\text{solution}} close to zero or negative. Therefore, for a series of similar salts, greater (i.e., more negative) hydration enthalpy leads to greater solubility, provided lattice energies do not change dramatically.

Now we examine how each of these enthalpies changes down Group 2, from magnesium to barium.

As we move down the group

Mg2+  →  Ca2+  →  Sr2+  →  Ba2+,Mg^{2+} \;\rightarrow\; Ca^{2+} \;\rightarrow\; Sr^{2+} \;\rightarrow\; Ba^{2+},

the ionic radius increases. A larger ion has a lower charge-to-radius ratio, so water molecules are held less strongly. Hence, the magnitude of the hydration enthalpy decreases sharply:

∣ΔHhydration(Mg2+)∣  >  ∣ΔHhydration(Ca2+)∣  >  ∣ΔHhydration(Sr2+)∣  >  ∣ΔHhydration(Ba2+)∣.|\Delta H_{\text{hydration}}(Mg^{2+})| \;>\; |\Delta H_{\text{hydration}}(Ca^{2+})| \;>\; |\Delta H_{\text{hydration}}(Sr^{2+})| \;>\; |\Delta H_{\text{hydration}}(Ba^{2+})|.

Lattice enthalpy also declines down the group because larger cations produce a smaller electrostatic attraction within the crystal. However, this fall is relatively gradual for sulphates.

The crucial point is that the decrease in the magnitude of hydration enthalpy down the group is much greater than the decrease in lattice enthalpy. Mathematically, if we write the change from one metal to the next as

ΔHsolution,new−ΔHsolution,old  =  (ΔHlattice,new−ΔHlattice,old)+(ΔHhydration,new−ΔHhydration,old),\Delta H_{\text{solution,new}} - \Delta H_{\text{solution,old}} \;=\; (\Delta H_{\text{lattice,new}} - \Delta H_{\text{lattice,old}}) + (\Delta H_{\text{hydration,new}} - \Delta H_{\text{hydration,old}}),

the second bracketed term (coming from hydration) is numerically larger and positive (because the negative value becomes less negative), so ΔHsolution\Delta H_{\text{solution}} becomes less negative or even positive. Consequently the salt becomes progressively less soluble.

Therefore, for the alkaline-earth metal sulphates the solubility trend is

MgSO4  >  CaSO4  >  SrSO4  >  BaSO4.MgSO_4 \;>\; CaSO_4 \;>\; SrSO_4 \;>\; BaSO_4.

Translating that chemical order to the symbols of the metals alone, we obtain

Mg  >  Ca  >  Sr  >  Ba.Mg \;>\; Ca \;>\; Sr \;>\; Ba.

This exactly matches Option A in the list:

Mg > Ca > Sr > Ba

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValency, oxidation states and nature of oxides
TypeMultiple choice