RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Ionisation enthalpy

The third ionization enthalpy is minimum for:

SOLUTION

The third ionization enthalpy is the energy needed to pull out the third electron from a gaseous neutral atom. Symbolically we write the three successive steps as

M(g)→ΔiH1M+(g)+e−,\text{M}(g) \xrightarrow{\Delta_iH_1} \text{M}^+(g) + e^-,

M+(g)→ΔiH2M2+(g)+e−,\text{M}^+(g) \xrightarrow{\Delta_iH_2} \text{M}^{2+}(g) + e^-,

M2+(g)→ΔiH3M3+(g)+e−.\text{M}^{2+}(g) \xrightarrow{\Delta_iH_3} \text{M}^{3+}(g) + e^-.

Here ΔiH3\Delta_iH_3 is the quantity we are comparing for Co, Fe, Ni and Mn.

Electrons are always removed first from the higher-energy 4s4s subshell and only afterwards from the 3d3d subshell. So, for any first-row transition element, the first two ionizations take away the two 4s4s electrons, and the third ionization removes the first 3d3d electron.

Let us write the ground-state electronic configurations (in the compact form using the argon core [ Ar ][\,\text{Ar}\,]):

Co : [ Ar ] 3d7 4s2[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7\,4s^2

Fe : [ Ar ] 3d6 4s2[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6\,4s^2

Ni : [ Ar ] 3d8 4s2[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8\,4s^2

Mn : [ Ar ] 3d5 4s2[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5\,4s^2

Now we remove electrons step by step.

Cobalt

First electron: [ Ar ] 3d7 4s2⟶[ Ar ] 3d7 4s1[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7\,4s^2 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7\,4s^1

Second electron: [ Ar ] 3d7 4s1⟶[ Ar ] 3d7[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7\,4s^1 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7

Third electron (from 3d3d): [ Ar ] 3d7⟶[ Ar ] 3d6[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6

The resulting Co3+\text{Co}^{3+} ion has configuration 3d63d^6, which is neither half-filled (3d53d^5) nor fully filled (3d103d^{10}). Therefore no extra stability is gained, so ΔiH3\Delta_iH_3 is not especially low.

Iron

First electron: [ Ar ] 3d6 4s2⟶[ Ar ] 3d6 4s1[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6\,4s^2 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6\,4s^1

Second electron: [ Ar ] 3d6 4s1⟶[ Ar ] 3d6[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6\,4s^1 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6

Third electron (from 3d3d): [ Ar ] 3d6⟶[ Ar ] 3d5[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^6 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5

Now the Fe3+\text{Fe}^{3+} ion possesses the exactly half-filled configuration 3d53d^5. A half-filled subshell enjoys extra exchange-energy stabilization; hence the energy needed to reach this state (the third ionization enthalpy) is markedly lower than for neighbouring elements.

Nickel

First electron: [ Ar ] 3d8 4s2⟶[ Ar ] 3d8 4s1[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8\,4s^2 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8\,4s^1

Second electron: [ Ar ] 3d8 4s1⟶[ Ar ] 3d8[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8\,4s^1 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8

Third electron: [ Ar ] 3d8⟶[ Ar ] 3d7[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^8 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^7

The 3d73d^7 configuration is not especially stable, so ΔiH3\Delta_iH_3 remains comparatively high.

Manganese

First electron: [ Ar ] 3d5 4s2⟶[ Ar ] 3d5 4s1[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5\,4s^2 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5\,4s^1

Second electron: [ Ar ] 3d5 4s1⟶[ Ar ] 3d5[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5\,4s^1 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5

Third electron: [ Ar ] 3d5⟶[ Ar ] 3d4[\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^5 \longrightarrow [\,\text{Ar}\,]\,3d^4

Here we destroy a half-filled subshell, so the third ionization enthalpy is actually very high, the opposite of what we want.

Among the four elements considered, only iron attains the extra-stable 3d53d^5 arrangement after losing its third electron. This additional stability lowers the required energy, making ΔiH3\Delta_iH_3 minimal for iron.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Ionisation enthalpy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicIonisation enthalpy
TypeMultiple choice