The size of the iso-electronic species Cl, Ar and Ca is affected by:
We begin by recalling that the term “iso-electronic species’’ refers to atoms or ions that possess exactly the same number of electrons. In our problem we have the chloride ion , the neutral argon atom and the calcium dication . Each of these species contains electrons in total, so the electronic configuration of all three is
Because the electron count and the distribution among the shells and subshells are identical, the principal quantum number for the outermost electrons is the same () and the azimuthal quantum numbers available in that shell (namely for the orbital and for the orbitals) are also the same for all three species. Hence, any difference in their ionic or atomic radii cannot arise from a change in either or , because those quantum numbers are fixed across the series. Likewise, since the total number of electrons is the same, the magnitude of electron-electron repulsions in equivalent orbitals is essentially similar.
The factor that does differ is the actual number of protons, i.e., the nuclear charge . We list the values:
The effective nuclear charge experienced by an electron is commonly represented by
where is the screening constant accounting for shielding by the other electrons. Since depends mainly on how many inner electrons are present—and here that number is the same for all three species—the variation in follows directly from the variation in .
As increases from to to , correspondingly increases. A higher effective nuclear charge pulls the common set of electrons closer to the nucleus, thereby reducing the ionic/atomic radius. Consequently we predict the size order
This trend is governed solely by the variation in nuclear charge. None of the other listed factors—azimuthal quantum number of the valence shell, electron-electron interactions (which remain comparable), or principal quantum number of the valence shell—changes among these iso-electronic species.
Hence, the factor affecting their relative sizes is the nuclear charge.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Electronegativity, effective nuclear charge and shielding. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.