RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Electron gain enthalpy

Within each pair of elements F and Cl, S and Se, and Li and Na, respectively, the elements that release more energy upon an electron gain are

SOLUTION

For any atom in the gaseous state, the quantity of energy released when one electron is added is called its electron-gain enthalpy (also called electron affinity). A larger release of energy means a more negative value of ΔegH\Delta_{\text{eg}}H and therefore a stronger tendency to accept an electron.

General periodic trends help us decide which element of each pair shows the larger (more negative) ΔegH\Delta_{\text{eg}}H :

• Along a period from left to right, nuclear charge increases and size decreases, so electron-gain enthalpy usually becomes more negative.

• Down a group, atomic size increases and the added electron feels less attraction, so ΔegH\Delta_{\text{eg}}H usually becomes less negative. However, very small atoms of the second period (such as F, O, N) suffer noticeably from inter-electronic repulsion in their compact 2p2p orbitals, producing some well-known exceptions.

Now we compare each given pair.

First pair: F\text{F} and Cl\text{Cl} lie in Group 17. Although fluorine is above chlorine, its tiny 2p2p subshell is already crowded, so the incoming electron experiences appreciable repulsion. Therefore the energy released on adding an electron is actually less for F than for Cl. In numbers, ΔegH(F)≈−328  kJ mol−1\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{F}) \approx -328\;\text{kJ mol}^{-1} whereas ΔegH(Cl)≈−349  kJ mol−1\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{Cl}) \approx -349\;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}. So chlorine releases more energy than fluorine.

Second pair: S\text{S} and Se\text{Se} belong to Group 16. Moving down from sulfur to selenium the atomic size grows, and there is no exceptional crowding because the comparison is between 3p3p (for S) and 4p4p (for Se) orbitals. Consequently ΔegH\Delta_{\text{eg}}H becomes less negative down the group. Hence ΔegH(S)\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{S}) is more negative than ΔegH(Se)\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{Se}), so sulfur releases more energy than selenium.

Third pair: Li\text{Li} and Na\text{Na} are the first two members of Group 1. For the alkali metals the usual down-the-group decrease in electron-gain enthalpy operates without any exceptions, because both Li\text{Li} and Na\text{Na} would place the extra electron into an ss orbital, and the size increase dominates. Numerically, ΔegH(Li)≈−60  kJ mol−1\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{Li}) \approx -60\;\text{kJ mol}^{-1} while ΔegH(Na)≈−53  kJ mol−1\Delta_{\text{eg}}H(\text{Na}) \approx -53\;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}. Therefore lithium releases more energy than sodium.

Collecting the conclusions: • Between F and Cl, the element releasing more energy is Cl\text{Cl}. • Between S and Se, the element releasing more energy is S\text{S}. • Between Li and Na, the element releasing more energy is Li\text{Li}.

Thus the required set is Cl,  S,  Li\text{Cl},\; \text{S},\; \text{Li}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Electron gain enthalpy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicElectron gain enthalpy
TypeMultiple choice