RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 06 SEP S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides

Among the sulphates of alkaline earth metals, the solubilities of BeSO4\text{BeSO}_4 and MgSO4\text{MgSO}_4 in water, respectively, are:

SOLUTION

We have to compare the solubilities of the sulphates of two successive Group 2 (alkaline-earth) elements, namely BeSO4\text{BeSO}_4 and MgSO4\text{MgSO}_4, when they are placed in water. To do this we recall the general principle that, for an ionic solid to dissolve, the magnitude of its hydration enthalpy must at least compensate for its lattice enthalpy.

For any salt M2+SO42−\text{M}^{2+}\text{SO}_4^{2-} belonging to the alkaline-earth series, two energetic quantities are important:

1. Lattice enthalpy, written ΔHlattice,\Delta H_{\text{lattice}}, which arises from the electrostatic attraction inside the crystal. 2. Hydration enthalpy, written ΔHhyd,\Delta H_{\text{hyd}}, which is released when the gaseous ions M2+\text{M}^{2+} and SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-} are surrounded by water molecules.

The overall enthalpy change for dissolution is

ΔHsolution=ΔHlattice+ΔHhyd.\Delta H_{\text{solution}} = \Delta H_{\text{lattice}} + \Delta H_{\text{hyd}}.

If ΔHsolution\Delta H_{\text{solution}} is negative or only slightly positive, the salt is appreciably soluble; if it is strongly positive, the salt remains largely undissolved.

Now we examine the periodic-trend arguments step by step:

• As we move down the Group 2 column, the ionic radius of M2+\text{M}^{2+} increases. So rBe2+<rMg2+<rCa2+…r_{\text{Be}^{2+}} < r_{\text{Mg}^{2+}} < r_{\text{Ca}^{2+}} \ldots

• Because lattice enthalpy roughly varies as z+z−r++r−,\dfrac{z^{+}z^{-}}{r^{+}+r^{-}}, a larger cation radius decreases lattice enthalpy. Hence ΔHlattice\Delta H_{\text{lattice}} becomes less negative (weaker in magnitude) from BeSO4 to MgSO4 to CaSO4, and so on.

• Hydration enthalpy varies approximately as z2r,\dfrac{z^{2}}{r}, so a smaller cation radius gives a more negative (more exothermic) ΔHhyd.\Delta H_{\text{hyd}}. Therefore the hydration enthalpy decreases markedly as we move down the group.

Combining the two trends:

Be}^{2+}: \; \Delta H_{\text{lattice}} \text{ very large negative}, \; \Delta H_{\text{hyd}} \text{ even more negative

Because the hydration enthalpy dominates, ΔHsolution\Delta H_{\text{solution}} is sufficiently negative, so BeSO4\text{BeSO}_4 dissolves readily — it is highly soluble.

Mg}^{2+}: \; \Delta H_{\text{lattice}} \text{ slightly smaller in magnitude}, \; \Delta H_{\text{hyd}} \text{ still large though less than Be}^{2+

The hydration enthalpy still outweighs the lattice enthalpy, and ΔHsolution\Delta H_{\text{solution}} remains near zero or slightly negative. Hence MgSO4\text{MgSO}_4 is also highly soluble in water. (Indeed, the familiar Epsom salt is MgSO4⋅7H2O,\text{MgSO}_4\cdot7\text{H}_2\text{O}, which dissolves easily.)

Starting with CaSO4\text{CaSO}_4 and continuing to BaSO4,\text{BaSO}_4, the hydration enthalpy drops below the lattice enthalpy, making those sulphates sparingly soluble; however, our question concerns only BeSO4 and MgSO4.

So the solubility pattern obtained is:

BeSO4: high\text{BeSO}_4 : \text{ high}

MgSO4: high\text{MgSO}_4 : \text{ high}

This matches Option C in the given list.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValency, oxidation states and nature of oxides
TypeMultiple choice