RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Atomic and ionic radii

The correct order of the ionic radii of O2−\text{O}^{2-}, N3−\text{N}^{3-}, F−\text{F}^-, Mg2+\text{Mg}^{2+}, Na+\text{Na}^+ and Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} is:

SOLUTION

We first note that the species O2−,  N3−,  F−,  Na+,  Mg2+\text{O}^{2-},\;\text{N}^{3-},\;\text{F}^- ,\;\text{Na}^+ ,\;\text{Mg}^{2+} and Al3+\text{Al}^{3+} all possess the same total number of electrons.

Counting one by one, we have:

N3−:  7+3=10 e−O2−:  8+2=10 e−F−:  9+1=10 e−Na+:  11−1=10 e−Mg2+:  12−2=10 e−Al3+:  13−3=10 e−\begin{aligned} \text{N}^{3-}: &\;7+3=10\text{ e}^- \\ \text{O}^{2-}: &\;8+2=10\text{ e}^- \\ \text{F}^- : &\;9+1=10\text{ e}^- \\ \text{Na}^+: &\;11-1=10\text{ e}^- \\ \text{Mg}^{2+}: &\;12-2=10\text{ e}^- \\ \text{Al}^{3+}: &\;13-3=10\text{ e}^- \end{aligned}

Since every ion contains 1010 electrons, they are termed isoelectronic.

For any series of isoelectronic ions, we use the fact that:

Ionic radius∝1Z\text{Ionic radius} \propto \frac1Z

where ZZ is the atomic number (nuclear charge). The mathematical statement above expresses that, with the electron cloud held constant, a larger positive nuclear charge pulls the same set of electrons closer, so the radius becomes smaller. Conversely, a smaller nuclear charge allows the cloud to expand, giving a larger radius.

We therefore list the atomic numbers:

Z(N)=7,Z(O)=8,Z(F)=9,Z(Na)=11,Z(Mg)=12,Z(Al)=13.\begin{aligned} Z(\text{N}) &= 7,\\ Z(\text{O}) &= 8,\\ Z(\text{F}) &= 9,\\ Z(\text{Na}) &= 11,\\ Z(\text{Mg}) &= 12,\\ Z(\text{Al}) &= 13. \end{aligned}

Now we arrange the ions from the highest ZZ (smallest radius) to the lowest ZZ (largest radius):

Al3+  (Z=13)  <  Mg2+  (Z=12)  <  Na+  (Z=11)  <  F−  (Z=9)  <  O2−  (Z=8)  <  N3−  (Z=7).\text{Al}^{3+}\;(Z=13)\; < \;\text{Mg}^{2+}\;(Z=12)\; < \;\text{Na}^+\;(Z=11)\; < \;\text{F}^-\;(Z=9)\; < \;\text{O}^{2-}\;(Z=8)\; < \;\text{N}^{3-}\;(Z=7).

Comparing this derived order with the given alternatives, we find perfect agreement with Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Atomic and ionic radii. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAtomic and ionic radii
TypeMultiple choice