Given below are two statements:
Statement I : None of the alkaline earth metal hydroxides dissolve in alkali.
Statement II : Solubility of alkaline earth metal hydroxides in water increases down the group.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
We begin by recalling that the hydroxides of the alkaline-earth metals have the general formula where stands for
The first point concerns their behaviour toward a concentrated external base (alkali). A hydroxide will dissolve in an alkali only if it is amphoteric, i.e. if it can react further with hydroxide ion to give a complex anion. The relevant amphoteric equilibrium is stated here:
Experimentally, only is sufficiently amphoteric to undergo this reaction. The other hydroxides - - are purely basic; they do not form the above complex and therefore do not dissolve in excess alkali. Hence the blanket statement “None of the alkaline-earth metal hydroxides dissolve in alkali” is false because is a clear counter-example.
Next we discuss the solubility of these hydroxides in water. Lattice energy () decreases more rapidly than hydration energy () when we go down the group, because the cationic radius increases markedly while the anionic radius (that of ) remains constant. The condition for dissolution is stated as
As falls down the group, this inequality becomes progressively easier to satisfy, causing solubility to rise in the order
Therefore the statement “Solubility of alkaline earth metal hydroxides in water increases down the group” is true.
Summarising, Statement I is incorrect whereas Statement II is correct. This matches Option B in the given list.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.