RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides

Two elements A and B have similar chemical properties. They don't form solid hydrogencarbonates, but react with nitrogen to form nitrides. A and B, respectively, are:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling a basic periodic-table idea known as the diagonal relationship. According to this concept, the first element of a period in the ss-block often shows properties similar to the second element of the next period lying diagonally below it. Thus, Li (Group 1, Period 2)\text{Li (Group 1, Period 2)} is diagonally related to Mg (Group 2, Period 3)\text{Mg (Group 2, Period 3)} and they exhibit many chemical similarities.

Now let us match the two special properties mentioned in the question with the behaviour of different ss-block elements:

1. They do not form solid hydrogencarbonates.

   • For most alkali metals, a salt such as NaHCO3\text{NaHCO}_{3} or KHCO3\text{KHCO}_{3} can be isolated in the solid state.
   • However, LiHCO3\text{LiHCO}_{3} is not stable as a solid. When an attempt is made to isolate it, it decomposes: 2 LiHCO3 (aq)  ⟶  Li2CO3 (s)+CO2+H2O.\text{2 LiHCO}_{3 \,(aq)} \;\longrightarrow\; \text{Li}_{2}\text{CO}_{3 \,(s)} + \text{CO}_{2} + \text{H}_{2}\text{O}.
   • A very similar situation exists for magnesium. The salt Mg(HCO3)2\text{Mg(HCO}_{3})_{2} only survives in aqueous solution; on heating or isolation it converts to MgCO3\text{MgCO}_{3}, releasing CO2\text{CO}_{2} and water.

2. They react with nitrogen to give nitrides.

   • Lithium burns in nitrogen to give the nitride Li3N\text{Li}_{3}\text{N}: 6Li+N2→2Li3N.6\text{Li} + \text{N}_{2} \rightarrow 2\text{Li}_{3}\text{N}.
   • Magnesium also combines directly with nitrogen to form Mg3N2\text{Mg}_{3}\text{N}_{2}: 3Mg+N2→Mg3N2.3\text{Mg} + \text{N}_{2} \rightarrow \text{Mg}_{3}\text{N}_{2}.

Both of these characteristic reactions are uncommon for the heavier alkali metals such as Na, K, Rb, Cs and for the heavier alkaline-earth metals like Ca, Sr, Ba. Thus, if two elements satisfy both conditions simultaneously, the only reasonable pair from the options is lithium and magnesium.

Let us quickly check the other options one by one:

   • Na\text{Na} and Rb\text{Rb} (Option A): sodium makes solid NaHCO3\text{NaHCO}_{3} and rubidium makes solid RbHCO3\text{RbHCO}_{3}, so this pair is ruled out.
   • Na\text{Na} and Ca\text{Ca} (Option B): sodium again forms a solid hydrogencarbonate; calcium forms solid Ca(HCO3)2\text{Ca(HCO}_{3})_{2} solutions that can be crystallised as double salts, so the property is not matched.
   • Cs\text{Cs} and Ba\text{Ba} (Option C): both form solid hydrogencarbonates under appropriate conditions; moreover they do not readily give stable binary nitrides in the same way Li and Mg do.
   • Li\text{Li} and Mg\text{Mg} (Option D): exactly fit the two conditions just verified.

Therefore, the pair A and B must be Li\text{Li} and Mg\text{Mg}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValency, oxidation states and nature of oxides
TypeMultiple choice