RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 02 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides

Both lithium and magnesium display several similar properties due to the diagonal relationship; however, the one which is incorrect is:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling that lithium (Li) is placed in Group 1 while magnesium (Mg) is in Group 2 of the periodic table, yet because they occupy diagonally adjacent positions (Li in period 2, Mg in period 3) they often exhibit what is called the diagonal relationship. This relationship causes many of their properties to resemble each other more closely than they resemble the other members of their respective groups.

To decide which of the four given statements is not a correct similarity, we shall examine every option one by one, writing out the relevant chemical facts and, wherever necessary, simple equations.

Option A — Both form soluble bicarbonates

The bicarbonate of lithium is LiHCO3LiHCO_3 and that of magnesium is Mg(HCO3)2Mg(HCO_3)_2. Both of these bicarbonates exist in aqueous solution and remain soluble. Chemically we may write their presence in water as

Li2CO3+CO2+H2O→2 LiHCO3Li_2CO_3 + CO_2 + H_2O \rightarrow 2\,LiHCO_3

MgCO3+CO2+H2O→Mg(HCO3)2MgCO_3 + CO_2 + H_2O \rightarrow Mg(HCO_3)_2

Because both bicarbonates are indeed soluble, statement A is true and therefore a correct similarity.

Option B — Both form nitrides

When heated in nitrogen, each metal reacts to give a nitride:

6 Li+N2→2 Li3N6\,Li + N_2 \rightarrow 2\,Li_3N

3 Mg+N2→Mg3N23\,Mg + N_2 \rightarrow Mg_3N_2

Thus both lithium and magnesium form stable nitrides, confirming that statement B is also true.

Option C — Nitrates of both Li and Mg yield NO2NO_2 and O2O_2 on heating

The thermal decomposition of lithium nitrate proceeds as

4 LiNO3→2 Li2O+4 NO2+O24\,LiNO_3 \rightarrow 2\,Li_2O + 4\,NO_2 + O_2

Magnesium nitrate behaves in an almost identical manner:

2 Mg(NO3)2→2 MgO+4 NO2+O22\,Mg(NO_3)_2 \rightarrow 2\,MgO + 4\,NO_2 + O_2

In both cases the products include NO2NO_2 and O2O_2, so statement C is again true.

Option D — Both form basic carbonate

First, let us understand what the phrase basic carbonate means. A basic carbonate is a salt that contains both carbonate CO32−CO_3^{2-} and hydroxide OH−OH^- ions within the same solid, for example

MgCO3⋅Mg(OH)2⋅5H2OMgCO_3 \cdot Mg(OH)_2 \cdot 5H_2O

This substance is commonly called basic magnesium carbonate. Magnesium definitely forms such a compound.

Now we check lithium. The only stable carbonate of lithium is the normal salt

Li2CO3Li_2CO_3

This carbonate does not contain any hydroxide ion in its lattice; nor is any solid compound of the type Li2CO3⋅LiOH⋅xH2OLi_2CO_3 \cdot LiOH \cdot xH_2O known under ordinary conditions. Therefore lithium does not form a basic carbonate.

Because the property is present for magnesium but absent for lithium, statement D is false. Hence it is the single incorrect similarity in the list.

After examining all four options we have found that only Option D fails to describe a genuine similarity arising from the diagonal relationship of Li and Mg.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Valency, oxidation states and nature of oxides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValency, oxidation states and nature of oxides
TypeMultiple choice