Consider the reaction: . The rate equation for this reaction is rate . Which of these mechanisms is/are consistent with this rate equation? (A) (slow); (fast). (B) (fast equilibrium); (slow).
The experimental rate law is given as
To check any proposed mechanism, write the rate law predicted by that mechanism and compare it with the experimental one.
Case 1: Mechanism A
Slow (rate-determining) step:
The rate is governed solely by this slow step:
This is exactly the experimentally observed form. Hence mechanism A is consistent with the given rate law.
Case 2: Mechanism B
Step (i) fast equilibrium:
Step (ii) slow (rate-determining):
Rate predicted by the slow step:
Because is an intermediate, express it using the fast equilibrium.
For equilibrium (i), let , so
Substituting:
This rate law contains an inverse dependence on , which is absent in the experimentally observed law. Therefore mechanism B does not reproduce the correct rate expression (unless is kept strictly constant, which is not stated).
Thus, only mechanism A is compatible with the experimental kinetics.
Option D which is: A only
Tagged Rate law, order and molecularity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.