RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

The group having triangular planar structure is:

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the basic idea that the shape of a molecule or ion is decided by the steric number of the central atom and the presence or absence of lone-pairs. For main-group species, we use the Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) concept.

The rule says: if the steric number is 33 and there are no lone-pairs on the central atom, the hybridisation is sp2sp^2 and the geometry is trigonal (triangular) planar. Whenever one of the three positions is occupied by a lone-pair, the shape becomes trigonal pyramidal instead of planar.

Now we examine every species that appears in the four option sets.

1. BF3BF_3  The central boron has three valence electrons and forms three σ\sigma bonds with three fluorine atoms. The steric number is 33 and there is no lone-pair on boron, so BF3BF_3 is sp2sp^2 hybridised and trigonal planar.

2. NF3NF_3  Nitrogen has five valence electrons. Three are used for three σ\sigma bonds with fluorine; the remaining two constitute one lone-pair. Thus steric number =3 bonds +1 lone-pair =4= 3 \text{ bonds } + 1 \text{ lone-pair } = 4, giving sp3sp^3 hybridisation and a trigonal pyramidal shape, not planar.

3. CO32−CO_3^{2-} (carbonate ion)  Carbon forms three σ\sigma bonds with three oxygen atoms. No lone-pair remains on carbon. Steric number =3=3, hybridisation sp2sp^2, shape trigonal planar.

4. NO3−NO_3^- (nitrate ion)  Nitrogen is bonded to three oxygen atoms with no lone-pair on nitrogen (the extra electron is delocalised in π\pi bonding). Steric number =3=3, hybridisation sp2sp^2, geometry trigonal planar.

5. SO3SO_3  Sulphur uses three σ\sigma bonds for three oxygen atoms; there is no lone-pair on sulphur in this structure. Steric number =3=3, hybridisation sp2sp^2, and the molecule is trigonal planar.

6. NH3NH_3  Three σ\sigma bonds + one lone-pair on nitrogen give steric number 44, sp3sp^3 hybridisation, and trigonal pyramidal shape.

7. NCl3NCl_3  Exactly analogous to NH3NH_3: three σ\sigma bonds + one lone-pair, hence trigonal pyramidal.

8. BCl3BCl_3  Like BF3BF_3, boron has no lone-pair; steric number 33, so sp2sp^2 and trigonal planar.

Having classified every species, we list those that are truly triangular planar:

BF3,  BCl3,  CO32−,  NO3−,  SO3BF_3,\; BCl_3,\; CO_3^{2-},\; NO_3^- ,\; SO_3

We now compare each option:

A. BF3,  NF3,  CO32−BF_3,\; NF_3,\; CO_3^{2-}  contains NF3NF_3 (pyramidal) – reject.

B. CO32−,  NO3−,  SO3CO_3^{2-},\; NO_3^-,\; SO_3  every member is trigonal planar – accept.

C. NH3,  SO3,  CO32−NH_3,\; SO_3,\; CO_3^{2-}  contains NH3NH_3 (pyramidal) – reject.

D. NCl3,  BCl3,  SO3NCl_3,\; BCl_3,\; SO_3  contains NCl3NCl_3 (pyramidal) – reject.

Only Option B satisfies the requirement that all species in the group possess a triangular planar structure.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice