RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Dipole moment and molecular polarity

The dipole moments of CCl4_4, CHCl3_3 and CH4_4 are in the order

SOLUTION

First, we recall the definition of dipole moment. The magnitude of the dipole moment is written as μ=q×d\mu = q \times d, where qq is the magnitude of charge and dd is the distance between the centres of positive and negative charges. In a molecule, the individual bond dipoles are treated as vectors, and the net dipole moment is obtained by vector (head-to-tail) addition of all the bond dipoles.

Now we analyse each of the three molecules one by one, keeping in mind their shapes and the directions of the individual bond dipoles.

For CH4CH_4 (methane) the molecular geometry is perfectly tetrahedral. All four C−HC-H bonds are identical and symmetrically oriented at equal angles of 109.5∘109.5^{\circ}. Each C−HC-H bond has a small bond dipole pointing from carbon towards hydrogen because carbon is slightly more electronegative than hydrogen. Because the four bond dipoles are equal in magnitude and symmetrically arranged, the vector sum of the four dipoles is exactly zero:

μ⃗CH4=μ⃗1+μ⃗2+μ⃗3+μ⃗4=0\vec{\mu}_{CH_4} = \vec{\mu}_1 + \vec{\mu}_2 + \vec{\mu}_3 + \vec{\mu}_4 = 0

Hence, μ(CH4)=0  Debye\mu(CH_4) = 0\;\text{Debye}. So methane is a non-polar molecule.

For CCl4CCl_4 (carbon tetrachloride) the geometry is again perfectly tetrahedral. Now each C−ClC-Cl bond dipole is larger in magnitude than a C−HC-H bond dipole because chlorine is much more electronegative than carbon. However, the four C−ClC-Cl bond dipoles are still equal in magnitude and symmetrically oriented at the tetrahedral angles. The vector addition again gives zero:

μ⃗CCl4=μ⃗1′+μ⃗2′+μ⃗3′+μ⃗4′=0\vec{\mu}_{CCl_4} = \vec{\mu}'_1 + \vec{\mu}'_2 + \vec{\mu}'_3 + \vec{\mu}'_4 = 0

Thus μ(CCl4)=0  Debye\mu(CCl_4) = 0\;\text{Debye} as well. Even though each individual C−ClC-Cl bond is quite polar, the symmetry causes complete cancellation.

For CHCl3CHCl_3 (chloroform) the molecular geometry is still tetrahedral, but now three positions are occupied by chlorine atoms and one position by a hydrogen atom. Let us denote the bond dipoles by vectors. Each C−ClC-Cl bond dipole is strong and points from carbon to chlorine, while the C−HC-H bond dipole is weak and points from carbon to hydrogen. The three identical C−ClC-Cl vectors do not cancel each other perfectly because they occupy only three corners of the tetrahedron; the fourth corner has a weaker C−HC-H dipole. When we add these four vectors, the much larger resultant of the three C−ClC-Cl vectors is only partially cancelled by the smaller C−HC-H vector. Consequently, a non-zero net dipole moment is obtained:

μ⃗CHCl3=(μ⃗C−Cl,1+μ⃗C−Cl,2+μ⃗C−Cl,3)+μ⃗C−H≠0\vec{\mu}_{CHCl_3} = (\vec{\mu}_{C-Cl,1} + \vec{\mu}_{C-Cl,2} + \vec{\mu}_{C-Cl,3}) + \vec{\mu}_{C-H} \neq 0

Thus μ(CHCl3)>0  Debye\mu(CHCl_3) > 0\;\text{Debye} and its value is significantly larger than the (zero) dipole moments of CH4CH_4 and CCl4CCl_4.

Collecting the results, we have

μ(CH4)=0,  μ(CCl4)=0,  μ(CHCl3)>0.\mu(CH_4) = 0,\; \mu(CCl_4) = 0,\; \mu(CHCl_3) > 0.

Therefore the order of dipole moments is

CH4=CCl4  <  CHCl3.CH_4 = CCl_4 \;<\; CHCl_3.

Among the given options, this corresponds exactly to

Option D: CH4=CCl4  <  CHCl3CH_4 = CCl_4 \;<\; CHCl_3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Dipole moment and molecular polarity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicDipole moment and molecular polarity
TypeMultiple choice