In which of the following pairs of molecules/ions, both the species are not likely to exist?
We start with the molecular-orbital (MO) theory for homonuclear diatomic species that are made only from the 1s atomic orbitals. In this very first MO set we have just two orbitals:
The bond order is obtained from the standard formula
where is the number of electrons in bonding orbitals and is the number of electrons in antibonding orbitals. A bond order that is zero or negative means the species cannot exist, whereas a positive bond order means the species can, at least in principle, exist.
Let us evaluate the bond order for every species that appears in the four options.
1. (0 electron)
Because two positive charges remove both electrons, we have
So is not expected to exist.
2. (2 electrons)
Configuration:
This molecule exists (ordinary hydrogen).
3. (1 electron)
Configuration:
Hence can exist.
4. (3 electrons)
Configuration:
Therefore is also, in principle, possible.
5. (4 electrons)
Configuration:
So is not expected to exist.
6. (2 electrons)
The double positive charge removes two electrons, leaving 2 electrons in total:
Configuration:
Thus should exist.
7. (6 electrons)
After the basic 1s set is filled (4 electrons), the extra two electrons enter the next higher bonding MO, . The order up to that point is
This gives
So can also exist according to MO theory.
Now we examine each option to see where both species have bond order zero.
A. (bond order 0) and (bond order 0) both non-existent.
B. (bond order 0.5) and (bond order 1) both exist.
C. (bond order 0.5) and (bond order 1) both exist.
D. (bond order 1) and (bond order 1) both exist.
Only option A contains a pair for which neither species is expected to exist.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Molecular orbital theory of diatomic species. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.