RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

The structure of PCl5\text{PCl}_5 in the solid state is:

SOLUTION

We recall first that PCl5\text{PCl}_5 shows different structures in different physical states. In the gaseous or liquid phase it behaves as a discrete, covalent molecule and adopts the trigonal bipyramidal\text{trigonal\ bipyramidal} geometry predicted from VSEPR theory for five electron pairs around phosphorus. However, when we cool the substance sufficiently to obtain the solid state, experimental X-ray diffraction studies reveal that individual PCl5\text{PCl}_5 molecules do not survive intact. Instead, each molecule ionises inside the crystal lattice.

The ionisation process can be written as

PCl5⟶[PCl4]++[PCl6]−.\text{PCl}_5 \longrightarrow [\text{PCl}_4]^+ + [\text{PCl}_6]^-.

Now we identify the geometries of the two ions produced.

1. For [PCl4]+[\text{PCl}_4]^+ we have a central phosphorus atom surrounded by four chloride ions. According to VSEPR theory, “four regions of electron density” around a central atom lead to the tetrahedral\text{tetrahedral} arrangement because a tetrahedron keeps the four bonding pairs as far apart as possible, minimising repulsion. Therefore [PCl4]+[\text{PCl}_4]^+ is tetrahedral.

2. For [PCl6]−[\text{PCl}_6]^- there are six chloride ions bonded to the central phosphorus atom. VSEPR tells us that “six regions of electron density” produce an octahedral\text{octahedral} shape, again because an octahedron best minimises repulsions among six bonding pairs. Hence [PCl6]−[\text{PCl}_6]^- is octahedral.

Combining these observations we see that the solid contains discrete [PCl4]+[\text{PCl}_4]^+ tetrahedral cations and [PCl6]−[\text{PCl}_6]^- octahedral anions packed together in an ionic lattice. This description matches exactly the statement given in Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice