RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 04 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

The reaction in which the hybridisation of the underlined atom is affected is

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling that the hybridisation of the central atom in any species is decided by the total number of σ-bonds plus lone pairs around that atom. A convenient expression for the steric number (SN) is

SN=12(V+M−C+A),\text{SN}=\frac12\left(V+M-C+A\right),

where

V=valence electrons of the central atom,V=\text{valence electrons of the central atom},

M=number of monovalent atoms attached,M=\text{number of monovalent atoms attached},

C=charge on the cation (if any),C=\text{charge on the cation (if any)},

A=charge on the anion (if any).A=\text{charge on the anion (if any)}.

The hybridisation is then

SN=2  ⇒  sp,SN=3  ⇒  sp2,SN=4  ⇒  sp3,SN=5  ⇒  sp3d,SN=6  ⇒  sp3d2.\begin{aligned} \text{SN}=2 &\;\Rightarrow\; sp,\\ \text{SN}=3 &\;\Rightarrow\; sp^2,\\ \text{SN}=4 &\;\Rightarrow\; sp^3,\\ \text{SN}=5 &\;\Rightarrow\; sp^3d,\\ \text{SN}=6 &\;\Rightarrow\; sp^3d^2. \end{aligned}

Now we analyse every option one by one, always determining the steric number before and after the reaction.

Option A: H3PO2‾  →disproportionation  PH3+H3PO3\underline{H_3PO_2}\;\overset{\text{disproportionation}}{\rightarrow}\;PH_3+H_3PO_3

• In H3PO2H_3PO_2 the phosphorus forms two P ⁣− ⁣HP\!-\!H σ\sigma-bonds, one P ⁣− ⁣OHP\!-\!OH σ\sigma-bond and contains one lone pair: SN =3σ+1 LP=4⇒sp3.=3\sigma+1\text{ LP}=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

• In PH3PH_3 the phosphorus has three P ⁣− ⁣HP\!-\!H bonds and one lone pair: SN =4⇒sp3.=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

• In H3PO3H_3PO_3 the phosphorus has three P ⁣− ⁣OHP\!-\!OH bonds and one lone pair: SN =4⇒sp3.=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

Because the hybridisation remains sp3sp^3 throughout, the underlined atom’s hybridisation is unchanged.

Option B: H2SO4+NaCl→420 K  NaHSO4+HClH_2SO_4+NaCl\overset{420\,\text{K}}{\rightarrow}\;NaHSO_4+HCl

• Sulphur in both H2SO4H_2SO_4 and NaHSO4NaHSO_4 is present in the tetrahedral SO42−\text{SO}_4^{2-} skeleton. Each has four σ-bonds and no lone pair on sulphur, so SN =4⇒sp3.=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

Hence the hybridisation of sulphur does not change.

Option C: NH3‾→H+NH4+\underline{NH_3}\overset{H^+}{\rightarrow}NH_4^+

• In NH3NH_3 we have three N ⁣− ⁣HN\!-\!H bonds and one lone pair: SN =4⇒sp3.=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

• In NH4+NH_4^+ we have four N ⁣− ⁣HN\!-\!H bonds and no lone pair: SN =4⇒sp3.=4\Rightarrow sp^3.

So the nitrogen retains sp3sp^3 hybridisation; no change occurs.

Option D: Xe‾F4+SbF5  ⟶  XeF3++SbF6−\underline{Xe}F_4+SbF_5\;\longrightarrow\;XeF_3^++SbF_6^-

• In XeF4XeF_4 xenon is surrounded by four Xe ⁣− ⁣FXe\!-\!F σ-bonds and two lone pairs: SN =4σ+2 LP=6⇒sp3d2.=4\sigma+2\text{ LP}=6\Rightarrow sp^3d^2. (This corresponds to the square-planar shape after accounting for lone-pair positions.)

• In XeF3+XeF_3^+ xenon carries three Xe ⁣− ⁣FXe\!-\!F σ-bonds and now only two lone pairs because of the positive charge: SN =3σ+2 LP=5⇒sp3d.=3\sigma+2\text{ LP}=5\Rightarrow sp^3d. The geometry becomes T-shaped.

Thus the steric number drops from 6 to 5 and the hybridisation changes from sp3d2sp^3d^2 to sp3d.sp^3d.

Among all the options, only in Option D does the underlined atom experience a change in hybridisation.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice