RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Molecular orbital theory of diatomic species

Of the species, NO, NO+^+, NO2+^{2+} and NO−^-, the one with minimum bond strength is:

SOLUTION

We have to compare the bond strengths of four related species. In Molecular Orbital (MO) theory, bond strength is directly connected with the bond order. A larger bond order means more bonding electrons (or fewer antibonding electrons), the bond becomes shorter and stronger; a smaller bond order means the bond is weaker.

The numerical relation is stated first:

Bond order  (B.O.)  =  Nb−Na2\text{Bond order} \; (B.O.) \;=\; \dfrac{N_b - N_a}{2}$

where NbN_b is the total number of electrons present in bonding molecular orbitals and NaN_a is the total number of electrons present in antibonding molecular orbitals.

For all second-period diatomic species (B2_2 to N2_2, O2_2, F2_2 and their ions) the order of the valence MOs that we must fill is the same:

σ(2s) < σ\*(2s) < σ(2pz) < π(2px)=π(2py) < π\*(2px)=π\*(2py) < σ\*(2pz)\sigma(2s)\,\lt \,\sigma^\*(2s)\,\lt \,\sigma(2p_z)\,\lt \,\pi(2p_x)=\pi(2p_y)\,\lt \,\pi^\*(2p_x)=\pi^\*(2p_y)\,\lt \,\sigma^\*(2p_z)$

Now we count the valence electrons in each species.

For atomic nitrogen, ZN=7Z_N = 7, so N(2s22p3)N(2s^2 2p^3) contributes 55 valence electrons.
For atomic oxygen, ZO=8Z_O = 8, so O(2s22p4)O(2s^2 2p^4) contributes 66 valence electrons.

Hence the neutral molecule NO has

5+6=11 valence electrons.5 + 6 = 11 \text{ valence electrons.}$

Starting from this neutral 11-electron case, we can reach the ions simply by adding or removing electrons:

NO   :  11 e−\; :\; 11 \text{ e}^-
NO+^+   :  10 e−\; :\; 10 \text{ e}^- (one electron removed)
NO2+^{2+} :  9 e−: \; 9 \text{ e}^- (two electrons removed)
NO−^- :  12 e−: \; 12 \text{ e}^- (one electron added)

Now we place these electrons into the MO ladder one by one and calculate NbN_b and NaN_a every time. Because the first four electrons (two in σ(2s)\sigma(2s) and two in σ\*(2s)\sigma^\*(2s)) cancel each other’s bonding effect, we can do the bookkeeping efficiently from the 5th electron onward, but for clarity every single filling step is shown.

(1) The neutral molecule NO   -  11 electrons

σ(2s)2    σ\*(2s)2    σ(2pz)2    π(2px)2    π(2py)2    π\*(2px)1\sigma(2s)^2\;\; \sigma^\*(2s)^2\;\; \sigma(2p_z)^2\;\; \pi(2p_x)^2\;\; \pi(2p_y)^2\;\; \pi^\*(2p_x)^1$

Bonding electrons: Nb=2+2+4=8N_b = 2 + 2 + 4 = 8
Antibonding electrons: Na=2+1=3N_a = 2 + 1 = 3

B.O.NO=8−32=52=2.5B.O._{\text{NO}} = \dfrac{8 - 3}{2} = \dfrac{5}{2} = 2.5

(2) The cation NO+^+   -  10 electrons

The electron removed comes from the highest-energy occupied orbital of NO, i.e. the antibonding π\*(2p)\pi^\*(2p). So after removal:

σ(2s)2    σ\*(2s)2    σ(2pz)2    π(2px)2    π(2py)2\sigma(2s)^2\;\; \sigma^\*(2s)^2\;\; \sigma(2p_z)^2\;\; \pi(2p_x)^2\;\; \pi(2p_y)^2$

Bonding electrons: Nb=2+2+4=8N_b = 2 + 2 + 4 = 8
Antibonding electrons: Na=2N_a = 2

B.O.NO+=8−22=3B.O._{\text{NO}^+} = \dfrac{8 - 2}{2} = 3

The bond order has increased, so the bond in NO+^+ is stronger than in NO.

(3) The dication NO2+^{2+}   -  9 electrons

The second electron must now be removed from the next highest occupied MO, which is a bonding π(2p)\pi(2p) orbital. We therefore have:

σ(2s)2    σ\*(2s)2    σ(2pz)2    π(2px)2    π(2py)1\sigma(2s)^2\;\; \sigma^\*(2s)^2\;\; \sigma(2p_z)^2\;\; \pi(2p_x)^2\;\; \pi(2p_y)^1$

Bonding electrons: Nb=2+2+(2+1)=7N_b = 2 + 2 + (2+1) = 7
Antibonding electrons: Na=2N_a = 2

B.O.NO2+=7−22=52=2.5B.O._{\text{NO}^{2+}} = \dfrac{7 - 2}{2} = \dfrac{5}{2} = 2.5

The bond order comes back down to 2.5, the same as the neutral molecule.

(4) The anion NO−^-   -  12 electrons

The extra electron has nowhere to go except the partially filled antibonding π\*(2p)\pi^\*(2p) level, giving:

σ(2s)2    σ\*(2s)2    σ(2pz)2    π(2px)2    π(2py)2    π\*(2px)2\sigma(2s)^2\;\; \sigma^\*(2s)^2\;\; \sigma(2p_z)^2\;\; \pi(2p_x)^2\;\; \pi(2p_y)^2\;\; \pi^\*(2p_x)^2$

Bonding electrons: Nb=2+2+4=8N_b = 2 + 2 + 4 = 8
Antibonding electrons: Na=2+2=4N_a = 2 + 2 = 4

B.O.NO−=8−42=2B.O._{\text{NO}^-} = \dfrac{8 - 4}{2} = 2

Now we compile the bond orders:

NO2+:2.5,NO+:3,NO:2.5,NO−:2\text{NO}^{2+} : 2.5,\quad \text{NO}^+ : 3,\quad \text{NO} : 2.5,\quad \text{NO}^- : 2$

The smallest bond order is 22, which belongs to NO−^-. Because bond strength decreases as bond order decreases, the species with the minimum bond strength is the anion NO−^-.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Molecular orbital theory of diatomic species. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicMolecular orbital theory of diatomic species
TypeMultiple choice