RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

In which of the following pairs the two species are not isostructural?

SOLUTION

Two species are called isostructural when they possess the same:
 • number of surrounding atoms (same steric number)
 • arrangement of these atoms in space (same molecular geometry / shape).
Hence we compare the VSEPR geometry of each pair.

Case A: CO32−CO_3^{2-} vs NO3−NO_3^-
Each ion has three σ\sigma-bonds to oxygen/nitrogen and no lone pair on the central atom.
Steric number =3=3 ⇒ hybridisation sp2sp^2 ⇒ trigonal-planar geometry.
Therefore the two ions are isostructural.

Case B: PCl4+PCl_4^+ vs SiCl4SiCl_4
Central PP in PCl4+PCl_4^+: 4 σ\sigma-bonds, no lone pair (positive charge has removed one electron).
Central SiSi in SiCl4SiCl_4: 4 σ\sigma-bonds, no lone pair.
Steric number =4=4 for both ⇒ hybridisation sp3sp^3 ⇒ tetrahedral geometry.
Thus they are isostructural.

Case C: PF5PF_5 vs BrF5BrF_5
• PF5PF_5: 5 σ\sigma-bonds, 0 lone pairs → steric number =5=5 → sp3dsp^3d hybridisation → trigonal bipyramidal shape.
• BrF5BrF_5: 5 σ\sigma-bonds, 1 lone pair → steric number =6=6 → sp3d2sp^3d^2 electronic geometry (octahedral), but one position occupied by a lone pair, giving a square pyramidal molecular shape.
Since trigonal bipyramidal ≠ square pyramidal, these two molecules are not isostructural.

Case D: AlF63−AlF_6^{3-} vs SF6SF_6
Both have 6 σ\sigma-bonds and no lone pair on the central atom.
Steric number =6=6 ⇒ sp3d2sp^3d^2 hybridisation ⇒ octahedral geometry.
Hence they are isostructural.

Among the four pairs, only Case C contains species with different shapes. Therefore the pair that is not isostructural is:

Option C which is: PF5PF_5 and BrF5BrF_5

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice