RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2007TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2007 Chemistry question — Fajans' rules, polarisation and covalent character

The charge/size ratio of a cation determines its polarizing power. Which one of the following sequences represents the increasing order of the polarizing power of the cationic species, K+,Ca2+,Mg2+,Be2+K^+, Ca^{2+}, Mg^{2+}, Be^{2+}?

SOLUTION

Polarising power is the ability of a cation to distort the electron cloud of an anion. It is directly proportional to the charge on the cation and inversely proportional to its ionic radius: polarising power∝z+r+\text{polarising power} \propto \frac{z^{+}}{r^{+}}, where z+z^{+} is the positive charge and r+r^{+} is the cationic radius.

Step 1 Compare charges.
K+K^{+} has charge +1+1, while Ca2+,  Mg2+,  Be2+Ca^{2+},\; Mg^{2+},\; Be^{2+} all have charge +2+2. Hence, with the same size, a doubly-charged ion would polarise more than a singly-charged ion.

Step 2 Compare sizes (radii decrease across a period and increase down a group).
Approximate ionic radii are
K+≈138 pmK^{+} \approx 138\text{ pm}, Ca2+≈100 pmCa^{2+} \approx 100\text{ pm}, Mg2+≈72 pmMg^{2+} \approx 72\text{ pm}, Be2+≈31 pmBe^{2+} \approx 31\text{ pm}.
Thus the size order is
K+>Ca2+>Mg2+>Be2+K^{+} \gt Ca^{2+} \gt Mg^{2+} \gt Be^{2+}.

Step 3 Combine charge and size to get z+r+\frac{z^{+}}{r^{+}} for each ion (qualitative comparison).
1138<2100<272<231\frac{1}{138} \lt \frac{2}{100} \lt \frac{2}{72} \lt \frac{2}{31}.

Hence the polarising power increases in the sequence
K+<Ca2+<Mg2+<Be2+K^{+} \lt Ca^{2+} \lt Mg^{2+} \lt Be^{2+}.

Therefore, the required increasing order is:
Option C which is: K+,  Ca2+,  Mg2+,  Be2+K^{+},\; Ca^{2+},\; Mg^{2+},\; Be^{2+}.

Tagged Fajans' rules, polarisation and covalent character. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicFajans' rules, polarisation and covalent character
TypeMultiple choice