RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2006TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2006 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

In which of the following molecules/ions are all the bonds not equal?

SOLUTION

The equality of bond lengths in a polyatomic species is governed by its molecular geometry. Species that place all equivalent ligands in symmetry-equivalent positions give identical bond lengths, whereas geometries having two distinct sets of positions (axial vs. equatorial) give two different bond lengths.

Case A : SF4SF_4
S has 66 valence electrons. Adding 44 electrons from the four FF atoms gives 1010 electrons, i.e. 55 electron pairs (one of them a lone pair).
 Hybridisation : sp3dsp^3d (trigonal bipyramidal electron-pair geometry).
 The lone pair occupies an equatorial position (maximum separation), so the geometry of the atoms is see-saw: two axial S-F bonds and two equatorial S-F bonds.
 Because axial-equatorial repulsions weaken the axial bonds (they are longer) while equatorial bonds are shorter, the four S-F bonds are not equal.

Case B : SiF4SiF_4
Si\mathrm{Si} has 44 valence electrons, giving 88 electrons (4 bonding pairs) around the central atom.
 Hybridisation : sp3sp^3 with a tetrahedral shape. All four FF atoms occupy symmetry-equivalent corners of a regular tetrahedron, hence all Si-F bond lengths are equal.

Case C : XeF4XeF_4
Xe contributes 88 valence electrons; with 44 electrons from FF atoms we have 1212 electrons (6 pairs: 4 bonding + 2 lone).
 Hybridisation : sp3d2sp^3d^2 with an octahedral electron-pair arrangement; the two lone pairs occupy positions trans to each other, giving a square-planar molecular geometry.
 All four FF atoms lie at the corners of the same square and are symmetry-equivalent, so every Xe-F bond length is identical.

Case D : BF4−BF_4^-
B provides 33 valence electrons, plus 11 extra due to the negative charge: total 44 electrons. With 44 electrons from the four FF atoms we again have 88 electrons (4 bonding pairs).
 Hybridisation : sp3sp^3 with a perfect tetrahedral geometry. All FF ligands are equivalent, giving equal B-F bond lengths.

Therefore, the only species in which there are two sets of distinct bond lengths is SF4SF_4.

Answer : Option A which is: SF4SF_4

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice