RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2006TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2006 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

The decreasing values of bond angles from NH3NH_3 (106∘)(106^\circ) to SbH3SbH_3 (101∘)(101^\circ) down group-15 of the periodic table is due to

SOLUTION

In all the hydrides EH3EH_3 of group-15 (E=N, P, As, SbE = N,\,P,\,As,\,Sb) the central atom is sp3sp^3 hybridised and carries one lone pair (lp) and three bond pairs (bp). For an ideal sp3sp^3 arrangement the bond angle is 109.5∘109.5^\circ, but lp-bp repulsion contracts it. Experimentally the bond angles are

NH3:106∘  >  PH3:94∘  >  AsH3:92∘  >  SbH3:101∘NH_3:106^\circ \; \gt \; PH_3:94^\circ \; \gt \; AsH_3:92^\circ \; \gt \; SbH_3:101^\circ (average ≈101∘\approx 101^\circ for SbH3SbH_3).

The decisive factor is the electronegativity of the central atom. Down the group the electronegativity decreases: N(3.0)>P(2.1)>As(2.0)>Sb(1.9)N(3.0) \gt P(2.1) \gt As(2.0) \gt Sb(1.9).

• A more electronegative central atom (as in NH3NH_3) attracts the bonding electrons towards itself; the bp electron clouds are pulled closer to the nucleus. This increases bp-bp and lp-bp repulsions, keeping the hydrogen atoms further apart and producing a larger ∠H ⁣− ⁣E ⁣− ⁣H\angle H\!-\!E\!-\!H.

• As electronegativity falls (from NH3NH_3 to SbH3SbH_3) the bonding electrons are held less tightly. The bp electron clouds spread out away from the central atom towards the hydrogens. Repulsion between the bp clouds therefore diminishes, allowing the three E−HE-H bonds to come closer together, and the H-E-H bond angle decreases.

Hence the progressive decrease of bond angle in EH3EH_3 is primarily due to the decreasing electronegativity of the central atom.

Option D which is: decreasing electronegativity

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice