RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

If AB4AB_4 molecule is a polar molecule, a possible geometry of AB4AB_4 is:

SOLUTION

A molecule is polar if the individual bond dipole moments do not cancel each other out. Highly symmetric molecular geometries cause these dipoles to cancel perfectly, resulting in a nonpolar molecule (μ=0\mu = 0).


Detailed Evaluation of Each Option:

  • Option A: Square Pyramidal

    • An AB4\text{AB}_4 molecule with a square pyramidal shape typically has a central atom with 4 bonding pairs and 1 lone pair (AB4E\text{AB}_4\text{E} type, like IF4−\text{IF}_4^-).
    • The four A–B\text{A--B} bonds form a square base, and their horizontal dipole components cancel each other out. However, the vertical dipole component from the lone pair at the apex is not counterbalanced by any bond or lone pair opposite to it.
    • Result: The molecule has a net dipole moment (μ≠0\mu \neq 0) and is polar. This is a possible geometry.

  • Option B: Tetrahedral

    • A regular tetrahedral geometry (AB4\text{AB}_4 type, like CH4\text{CH}_4 or CCl4\text{CCl}_4) has a perfectly symmetrical distribution of identical surrounding atoms around the central atom.
    • The dipoles of all four identical bonds point toward the corners of a regular tetrahedron and cancel each other out exactly.
    • Result: Net dipole moment is zero (μ=0\mu = 0); the molecule is nonpolar.

  • Option C: Rectangular Planar

    • In a rectangular planar geometry, the four surrounding atoms lie in a single plane at the corners of a rectangle.
    • The bond dipoles opposite to each other are equal in magnitude and directly opposite in direction (180∘180^\circ apart), leading to complete cancellation.
    • Result: Net dipole moment is zero (μ=0\mu = 0); the molecule is nonpolar.

  • Option D: Square Planar

    • A square planar geometry (AB4E2\text{AB}_4\text{E}_2 type, like XeF4\text{XeF}_4) places four identical bonds at 90∘90^\circ angles to each other in a single plane, with two lone pairs positioned vertically opposite (180∘180^\circ) to each other.
    • Both the bond dipoles and the lone pair dipoles cancel out perfectly due to the symmetric configuration.
    • Result: Net dipole moment is zero (μ=0\mu = 0); the molecule is nonpolar.

Conclusion:

Among the given arrangements, tetrahedral, rectangular planar, and square planar geometries are perfectly symmetrical and lead to a nonpolar molecule. Only a square pyramidal arrangement breaks this directional symmetry, resulting in a polar molecule.

Answer: Option A — Square pyramidal

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice