RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

Which of the following conversions involves change in both shape and hybridisation?

SOLUTION

To identify the conversion that shows a change in both geometric shape and hybridisation, we examine every option one by one.

Option A : H2O  →  H3O+H_2O \;\rightarrow\; H_3O^+

For the water molecule H2OH_2O the central atom is oxygen. Oxygen has the ground-state configuration 1s2 2s2 2p41s^2\,2s^2\,2p^4. In H2OH_2O it forms two σ-bonds with hydrogen and possesses two lone pairs. The steric number is therefore

Steric number=number of σ-bonds+lone pairs=2+2=4.\text{Steric number}= \text{number of σ-bonds}+ \text{lone pairs}=2+2=4.

For steric number 44 we recall the rule:

Steric number 4  ⟶  sp3 hybridisation.\text{Steric number }4 \;\longrightarrow\; sp^3 \text{ hybridisation.}

Hence H2OH_2O is sp3sp^3 hybridised. With two bonding and two lone pairs, the observed shape (after taking lone-pair repulsion into account) is bent.

In the ion H3O+H_3O^+ oxygen forms three σ-bonds with hydrogen and carries one lone pair. The steric number again is 3+1=43+1=4, so the hybridisation remains sp3sp^3. With one lone pair the shape is now trigonal pyramidal. Thus the shape changes (bent →\rightarrow pyramidal) but the hybridisation stays the same (sp3sp^3). Therefore Option A does not satisfy the condition.

Option B : BF3  →  BF4−BF_3 \;\rightarrow\; BF_4^-

For BF3BF_3 the central atom boron has three σ-bonds to fluorine and no lone pair. The steric number is 3+0=33+0=3, and we use the rule:

Steric number 3  ⟶  sp2 hybridisation.\text{Steric number }3 \;\longrightarrow\; sp^2 \text{ hybridisation.}

The three sp2sp^2 orbitals lie in one plane at 120∘120^\circ, so the molecular shape is trigonal planar.

In the tetrafluoroborate ion BF4−BF_4^- boron forms four σ-bonds with fluorine and again has no lone pair. The steric number is 4+0=44+0=4, leading to

Steric number 4  ⟶  sp3 hybridisation.\text{Steric number }4 \;\longrightarrow\; sp^3 \text{ hybridisation.}

The four sp3sp^3 orbitals point toward the corners of a regular tetrahedron, giving a tetrahedral shape.

Here we observe:

Shape changes:  trigonal planar →\rightarrow tetrahedral.

Hybridisation changes:  sp2  →  sp3.sp^2 \;\rarr\; sp^3.

Both properties change, so Option B satisfies the requirement.

Option C : CH4  →  C2H6CH_4 \;\rightarrow\; C_2H_6

In methane CH4CH_4 carbon makes four σ-bonds and has zero lone pairs, giving steric number 44 and hybridisation sp3sp^3 with a tetrahedral shape.

In ethane C2H6C_2H_6 each carbon still forms four σ-bonds (three to H and one to the other carbon) with no lone pairs, so each carbon remains sp3sp^3 and the local shape around each carbon is still tetrahedral. Neither the hybridisation nor the shape changes, so Option C is eliminated.

Option D : NH3  →  NH4+NH_3 \;\rightarrow\; NH_4^+

For NH3NH_3, nitrogen has three σ-bonds and one lone pair, giving steric number 44 ⇒\Rightarrow sp3sp^3 hybridisation. One lone pair leads to a trigonal pyramidal shape.

In NH4+NH_4^+ nitrogen forms four σ-bonds and has no lone pair, steric number 44 ⇒\Rightarrow still sp3sp^3 hybridised, with a tetrahedral shape. Thus the shape changes but the hybridisation remains sp3sp^3, so Option D also fails the “both change” condition.

Among all four possibilities, only Option B (BF3→BF4−BF_3 \rightarrow BF_4^-) exhibits a simultaneous change in both hybridisation (from sp2sp^2 to sp3sp^3) and molecular shape (from trigonal planar to tetrahedral).

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice