RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

The decreasing order of bond angles in BF3_3, NH3_3, PF3_3 and I3−_3^- is:

SOLUTION

First, we recall the VSEPR (Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion) principle which states that electron pairs surrounding a central atom arrange themselves in space so that the repulsion between them is minimized. The order of repulsion is

lone pair-lone pair  >  lone pair-bond pair  >  bond pair-bond pair.\text{lone pair-lone pair} \; > \; \text{lone pair-bond pair} \; > \; \text{bond pair-bond pair}.

More repulsion between pairs forces the bonded atoms farther apart, thus producing a larger bond angle. Conversely, less repulsion gives a smaller bond angle.

Analyzing each species one by one

We have BF3\text{BF}_3. Boron contributes three valence electrons and each fluorine donates one electron for the bond, giving a total of three bond pairs and, importantly, no lone pair on the central boron. According to VSEPR, 33 bond pairs adopt a trigonal-planar geometry. The standard bond angle for a perfect trigonal plane is

120∘.120^\circ.

Next, we look at NH3\text{NH}_3. Nitrogen has five valence electrons. It forms three σ\sigma bonds with three hydrogen atoms (three bond pairs) and is left with one lone pair. Thus, there are 44 regions of electron density (three bond pairs + one lone pair). VSEPR tells us that the electron pairs would choose a tetrahedral electron-pair arrangement, whose ideal bond angle is 109.5∘109.5^\circ. However, one of these positions is occupied by a lone pair, and we already know

lone pair-bond pair repulsion>bond pair-bond pair repulsion.\text{lone pair-bond pair repulsion} > \text{bond pair-bond pair repulsion}.

This extra repulsion squeezes the three N-H\text{N-H} bonds closer together, reducing the angle from the ideal 109.5∘109.5^\circ to about

107∘.107^\circ.

Now consider PF3\text{PF}_3. Phosphorus is in the same group as nitrogen but one period lower. It also has five valence electrons, so it similarly forms three σ\sigma bonds with fluorine and retains one lone pair. Thus the qualitative geometry is again trigonal-pyramidal. Nevertheless, two additional factors decrease the bond angle relative to NH3\text{NH}_3:

(i) The larger size of the central phosphorus nucleus spreads the bonding pairs slightly farther from each other.

(ii) Fluorine is highly electronegative, pulling bonding electron density toward itself. This diminishes the bond-pair electron density close to phosphorus, so bond pair-bond pair\text{bond pair-bond pair} repulsion becomes weaker. A weaker repulsion allows the angle to contract further.

Experimentally the F-P-F\text{F-P-F} bond angle is found to be close to

96∘.96^\circ.

Finally we examine I3−\text{I}_3^-. The central iodine atom is surrounded by two bond pairs (the two terminal I atoms) and three lone pairs, giving a total of 55 electron pairs. According to VSEPR, five electron pairs adopt a trigonal-bipyramidal electron-pair geometry. Of these, the three lone pairs preferentially occupy the equatorial positions (to minimize lone-pair-lone-pair repulsion), while the two bond pairs occupy the two axial positions. Axial positions in a trigonal-bipyramidal arrangement are located in a straight line, so the I-I-I\text{I-I-I} bond angle becomes

180∘,180^\circ,

i.e. the molecule is linear.

Putting the values in descending order

180∘  (I3−)  >  120∘  (BF3)  >  107∘  (NH3)  >  96∘  (PF3).180^\circ \; (\text{I}_3^-) \; > \; 120^\circ \; (\text{BF}_3) \; > \; 107^\circ \; (\text{NH}_3) \; > \; 96^\circ \; (\text{PF}_3).

Writing the corresponding molecular formulas in the same sequence gives

I3−  >  BF3  >  NH3  >  PF3.\text{I}_3^- \; > \; \text{BF}_3 \; > \; \text{NH}_3 \; > \; \text{PF}_3.

This matches exactly with Option A in the question statement.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice