RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions

Identify the pair in which the geometry of the species is T-shape and square pyramidal, respectively:

SOLUTION

To decide the geometry of every species we shall apply the VSEPR (Valence-Shell Electron-Pair Repulsion) model, which states that the arrangement of electron-pairs around the central atom is the one that minimises repulsions. The steric number, SN = (number of sigma bonds) + (number of lone pairs), tells us the basic electron-pair geometry, after which the positions of the lone pairs decide the final molecular shape.

Option A ICl_2−\_2^- and ICl_5\_5

ICl_2−\_2^- : The central iodine has two sigma bonds and three lone pairs, so SN=2+3=5\text{SN}=2+3=5, giving a trigonal-bipyramidal electron skeleton. Placing the three lone pairs in the equatorial belt leaves the two Cl atoms axial, producing a linear, not T-shaped, molecule.

ICl_5\_5 : Iodine has five sigma bonds and one lone pair, so SN=5+1=6\text{SN}=5+1=6, i.e. an octahedral skeleton. One lone pair occupies one position, leaving a square pyramidal shape. Thus the first member is not T-shaped, so the pair fails.

Option B IO_3−\_3^- and IO_2\_2F_2−\_2^-

IO_3−\_3^- : Three sigma bonds + one lone pair ⇒\Rightarrow SN=4\text{SN}=4, giving a tetrahedral skeleton and a trigonal-pyramidal shape.

IO_2\_2F_2−\_2^- : Four sigma bonds + one lone pair ⇒\Rightarrow SN=5\text{SN}=5, giving a trigonal-bipyramidal skeleton. With one lone pair, the shape is see-saw, not square pyramidal. Hence option B is wrong.

Option C ClF_3\_3 and IO_4−\_4^-

ClF_3\_3 : Three sigma bonds + two lone pairs ⇒\Rightarrow SN=5\text{SN}=5, electron skeleton trigonal-bipyramidal. The two lone pairs occupy equatorial positions, so the three F atoms form a T-shape. Good so far.

IO_4−\_4^- : Four sigma bonds + zero lone pairs ⇒\Rightarrow SN=4\text{SN}=4, giving a tetrahedral shape, not square pyramidal. Therefore option C is eliminated.

Option D XeOF_2\_2 and XeOF_4\_4

We now examine both species carefully.

XeOF_2\_2

• Valence electrons on Xe = 8. • One O atom and two F atoms each form one sigma bond with Xe, so there are three sigma bonds. • The total steric number around Xe is obtained from SN  =  valence electrons of Xe+number of monovalent atoms−charge2=8+3−02=5.\text{SN} \;=\; \frac{\text{valence electrons of Xe} + \text{number of monovalent atoms} - \text{charge}}{2} = \frac{8 + 3 - 0}{2} = 5. (Here O is counted once because it provides one sigma bond.) • With SN=5\text{SN}=5 the electron-pair geometry is trigonal bipyramidal. We still have 5−3=25 - 3 = 2 lone pairs to place. According to VSEPR, lone pairs prefer equatorial sites to minimise 90° repulsions, so both lone pairs go equatorial. The remaining three bonded atoms (O, F, F) occupy two axial and one equatorial position which produces a right-angled arrangement, i.e. a T-shape. So XeOF_2\_2 is T-shaped.

XeOF_4\_4

• Valence electrons on Xe = 8. • One O atom + four F atoms give five sigma bonds. • The steric number is SN=8+5−02=6.\text{SN} = \frac{8 + 5 - 0}{2} = 6. • SN=6\text{SN}=6 corresponds to an octahedral electron skeleton. The total lone pairs are 6−5=1.6 - 5 = 1. • Placing the single lone pair in any one of the six positions of an octahedron leaves a square base of four ligands with the fifth ligand occupying the position trans to the lone pair. This yields a square pyramidal molecular geometry. Hence XeOF_4\_4 is square pyramidal.

Thus, in option D the first species (XeOF_2\_2) is T-shaped and the second species (XeOF_4\_4) is square pyramidal. No other option satisfies the required pair of shapes.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged VSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicVSEPR theory and shapes of molecules and ions
TypeMultiple choice