RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2023 · 13 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2023 Chemistry question — Dipole moment and molecular polarity

Among the following compounds, the one which shows highest dipole moment is

SOLUTION

The dipole moment μ\mu of a hetero-atomic bond is the product of the magnitude of charge separation qq and the bond length rr, i.e. μ=q r\mu = q\,r (expressed in Debye, D).
A larger electronegativity difference increases qq, while a longer bond increases rr. Hence, to compare dipole moments we must examine the combined effect of both factors.

For the tetrahedral molecules CH3XCH_3X (where X=F,Cl,Br,IX = F, Cl, Br, I) the three nearly coplanar C-H bonds have dipoles that almost cancel one another. The net molecular dipole therefore points almost entirely along the C-X bond. Consequently,

μ(CH3X)≈μ(C-X)=q C-X  r C-X−(1)\mu(CH_3X) \approx \mu(\text{C-}X) = q_{\,\text{C-}X}\; r_{\,\text{C-}X} \quad -(1)

Let us analyse both factors moving down the halogen group:

Electronegativity difference (controls qq)
Δχ(C-X):  F>Cl>Br>I\Delta\chi(\text{C-}X):\; F \gt Cl \gt Br \gt I
Thus q C-F>q C-Cl>q C-Br>q C-Iq_{\,\text{C-}F} \gt q_{\,\text{C-}Cl} \gt q_{\,\text{C-}Br} \gt q_{\,\text{C-}I}.

Bond length (controls rr)
C-F (1.39 Å) < C-Cl (1.78 Å) < C-Br (1.94 Å) < C-I (2.14 Å)

Putting the two trends together:

  • From F →\rightarrow Cl the decrease in qq is modest, whereas the increase in rr is substantial (≈0.39 Å).
  • From Cl →\rightarrow Br →\rightarrow I both factors (qq decreases and rr increases only slightly) lower the product q rq\,r.

Experimental dipole moments corroborate this assessment:

  • μ(CH3F)=1.85  D\mu(CH_3F) = 1.85\;\text{D}
  • μ(CH3Cl)=1.87  D\mu(CH_3Cl) = 1.87\;\text{D}
  • μ(CH3Br)=1.79  D\mu(CH_3Br) = 1.79\;\text{D}
  • μ(CH3I)=1.64  D\mu(CH_3I) = 1.64\;\text{D}

The slight fall in charge separation from F to Cl is more than compensated by the longer C-Cl bond, giving CH3ClCH_3Cl the highest dipole moment of the four molecules.

Hence, among the compounds listed, the molecule with the greatest dipole moment is CH3Cl\mathbf{CH_3Cl}.

Option A which is: CH3ClCH_3Cl

Tagged Dipole moment and molecular polarity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicDipole moment and molecular polarity
TypeMultiple choice