RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Resonance and bond parameters

The bond angle H-X-H is the greatest in the compound:

SOLUTION

First, we recall VSEPR theory, which predicts molecular shapes by counting bond pairs\text{bond pairs} and lone pairs\text{lone pairs} on the central atom. The rule states that regions of electron density repel each other and arrange to minimize repulsion, deciding both shape and bond angles.

We list each molecule, the central atom, its valence electrons, the number of bonding pairs with hydrogen, and the number of lone pairs.

For PH3PH_3 we have: PP is in group 15, so 55 valence electrons. Bonding with three HH atoms uses 33 pairs, leaving 5−3=25-3=2 electrons, i.e. 11 lone pair. Thus there are 44 regions of electron density (3 bond pairs + 1 lone pair), giving a trigonal-pyramidal arrangement. By experience and experimental data, the bond angle is close to 93.5∘93.5^{\circ} because the larger, more diffuse 3p3p orbitals of phosphorus do not overlap strongly with 1s1s of hydrogen, so bond-bond repulsion is weak.

For CH4CH_4 we have: CC is in group 14 with 44 valence electrons. It forms 44 sigma bonds with HH, using all its electrons and leaving 00 lone pairs. Thus there are exactly 44 regions of electron density, all bond pairs. According to VSEPR, 44 bond pairs adopt a regular tetrahedral geometry. The standard tetrahedral bond angle is 109∘28′\displaystyle 109^{\circ}28' (commonly written as 109.5∘109.5^{\circ}).

For NH3NH_3 we have: NN is in group 15 with 55 valence electrons. After making 33 N-H bonds, 5−3=25-3=2 electrons remain as 11 lone pair. Again we get 44 regions of electron density (3 bond pairs + 1 lone pair), giving a trigonal-pyramidal shape. However, nitrogen’s 2p2p orbitals are small and overlap well with hydrogen’s 1s1s, producing stronger bond-bond repulsion than in PH3PH_3. Still, the lone pair exerts extra repulsion and compresses the H-N-H angle to about 107∘107^{\circ}, which is less than the tetrahedral value.

For H2OH_2O we have: OO belongs to group 16 with 66 valence electrons. Two electrons form two O-H bonds, so 6−2=46-2=4 electrons remain as 22 lone pairs. Now the total is 44 regions of electron density (2 bond pairs + 2 lone pairs), leading to a bent (angular) geometry. Two lone pairs repel even more strongly, squeezing the H-O-H angle down to about 104.5∘104.5^{\circ}.

Now we compare the numerical bond angles obtained:

PH3:≈93.5∘PH_3 : \approx 93.5^{\circ}

NH3:≈107∘NH_3 : \approx 107^{\circ}

H2O:≈104.5∘H_2O : \approx 104.5^{\circ}

CH4:109.5∘CH_4 : 109.5^{\circ}

The greatest of these is clearly the tetrahedral angle 109.5∘109.5^{\circ} in CH4CH_4.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Resonance and bond parameters. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicResonance and bond parameters
TypeMultiple choice