RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Chemistry question — Molecular orbital theory of diatomic species

After understanding the assertion and reason, choose the correct option.
Assertion: In the bonding molecular orbital (MO) of H2H_2, electron density is increased between the nuclei.
Reason: The bonding MO is ψA+ψB\psi_A + \psi_B, which shows destructive interference of the combining electron waves.

SOLUTION

First, let's understand the Assertion and Reason given in the question.

The Assertion states: In the bonding molecular orbital (MO) of H2H_2, electron density is increased between the nuclei.

The Reason states: The bonding MO is ψA+ψB\psi_A + \psi_B, which shows destructive interference of the combining electron waves.

To evaluate these, we need to recall how molecular orbitals are formed in the hydrogen molecule (H2H_2). Each hydrogen atom contributes a 1s atomic orbital, denoted as ψA\psi_A for atom A and ψB\psi_B for atom B. When these atomic orbitals combine, they form two molecular orbitals: a bonding molecular orbital (BMO) and an antibonding molecular orbital (ABMO).

The bonding molecular orbital (BMO) is formed by the constructive interference (in-phase combination) of the atomic orbitals. This is mathematically represented as:

ψBMO=ψA+ψB\psi_{\text{BMO}} = \psi_A + \psi_B

The antibonding molecular orbital (ABMO) is formed by the destructive interference (out-of-phase combination) and is represented as:

ψABMO=ψA−ψB\psi_{\text{ABMO}} = \psi_A - \psi_B

Now, the electron density in a molecular orbital is given by the square of the wave function, ∣ψ∣2|\psi|^2. Let's compute this for the bonding MO:

∣ψBMO∣2=(ψA+ψB)2=ψA2+ψB2+2ψAψB|\psi_{\text{BMO}}|^2 = (\psi_A + \psi_B)^2 = \psi_A^2 + \psi_B^2 + 2\psi_A\psi_B

For the antibonding MO:

∣ψABMO∣2=(ψA−ψB)2=ψA2+ψB2−2ψAψB|\psi_{\text{ABMO}}|^2 = (\psi_A - \psi_B)^2 = \psi_A^2 + \psi_B^2 - 2\psi_A\psi_B

In the region between the two nuclei, both ψA\psi_A and ψB\psi_B are positive because the 1s atomic orbitals are positive everywhere. Therefore, in the bonding MO, the cross term 2ψAψB2\psi_A\psi_B is positive. This means that the electron density between the nuclei is higher than the sum of the individual atomic orbital densities (ψA2+ψB2\psi_A^2 + \psi_B^2). Thus, the Assertion is correct: in the bonding MO, electron density is indeed increased between the nuclei.

Now, let's examine the Reason. It claims that the bonding MO is ψA+ψB\psi_A + \psi_B, which is correct, but it states that this represents destructive interference. However, as explained above, ψA+ψB\psi_A + \psi_B corresponds to constructive interference (in-phase combination), which leads to increased electron density between the nuclei. Destructive interference occurs in the antibonding MO (ψA−ψB\psi_A - \psi_B), where the electron density between the nuclei is reduced. Therefore, the Reason is incorrect because it misattributes destructive interference to the bonding MO.

Given that the Assertion is correct and the Reason is incorrect, we now look at the options:

A. Assertion and Reason are correct, but Reason is not the correct explanation for the Assertion.

B. Assertion and Reason are correct and Reason is the correct explanation for the Assertion.

C. Assertion is incorrect, Reason is correct.

D. Assertion is correct, Reason is incorrect.

Since the Assertion is correct and the Reason is incorrect, the correct choice is D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Molecular orbital theory of diatomic species. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicMolecular orbital theory of diatomic species
TypeMultiple choice