[P] on treatment with in produced a single isomer while heating [P] with sodalime gives toluene. The compound [P] is:
The molecular formula of the monobrominated product is .
During bromination one hydrogen atom is replaced by bromine, so the parent compound [P] must be .
Heating [P] with sodalime (NaOH + CaO) carries out decarboxylation, i.e. .
Because the decarboxylation product is toluene (), [P] must be an aromatic carboxylic acid containing one extra carbon compared to toluene. Therefore [P] is some isomer of (methyl-benzoic acid, also called toluic acid).
The three possible isomers are:
• o-methylbenzoic acid (2-toluic acid)
• m-methylbenzoic acid (3-toluic acid)
• p-methylbenzoic acid (4-toluic acid)
We now use the bromination data. Electrophilic bromination in is governed by the directing effects of the substituents present:
Case 1: o-methylbenzoic acid
• The ring positions 3, 4, 5, 6 are all chemically nonequivalent and at least two of them are activated for substitution, so a mixture of brominated isomers would be obtained.
Case 2: m-methylbenzoic acid
• Again several positions (2, 4, 5, 6) differ in reactivity, giving more than one monobromo product.
Case 3: p-methylbenzoic acid
• Place at position 1 and at position 4.
• Both groups favour substitution at positions 3 and 5:
- For these are its meta positions.
- For these are its ortho positions.
• Positions 3 and 5 are equivalent by symmetry, so only one distinct monobromo isomer can form.
Thus only p-methylbenzoic acid satisfies the statement “produced a single isomer ”.
Therefore, the compound [P] is p-methylbenzoic acid (4-methylbenzoic acid).
Option A which is: p-methylbenzoic acid.
Tagged Reactions of carboxylic acids. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.