RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2005TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2005 Chemistry question — Acidity of carboxylic acids

Among the following acids which has the lowest pKaK_a value

SOLUTION

The acidity order of aliphatic carboxylic acids is governed mainly by the inductive effect ( +I+I effect ) of the alkyl groups attached to the carboxyl carbon.

1. When an acid loses H+H^+ it forms the carboxylate ion RCOO−RCOO^-.
2. An alkyl group RR is electron-donating ( +I+I ). It pushes electron density toward the negatively charged COO−COO^- group, destabilising it.
3. Greater destabilisation of the anion means lower acid strength, hence higher pKapK_a.

Therefore:
• No alkyl group (formic acid, HCOOHHCOOH) ⇒ maximum stability of HCOO−HCOO^- ⇒ strongest acid ⇒ lowest pKapK_a.
• One methyl group (acetic acid, CH3COOHCH_3COOH) weakens the acid slightly.
• One ethyl group (propionic acid, CH3CH2COOHCH_3CH_2COOH) has a stronger +I+I effect than methyl, so the acid is still weaker.
• Two methyl groups (CH3)2CHCOOH(CH_3)_2CHCOOH (isobutyric acid) give the largest +I+I effect, making it the weakest acid of the set.

Hence the acidity (and Ka) order is
HCOOH  >  CH3COOH  >  CH3CH2COOH  >  (CH3)2CHCOOHHCOOH \; \gt \; CH_3COOH \; \gt \; CH_3CH_2COOH \; \gt \; (CH_3)_2CHCOOH
corresponding to the lowest pKapK_a for formic acid.

Option B which is: HCOOH

Tagged Acidity of carboxylic acids. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAcidity of carboxylic acids
TypeMultiple choice