RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S2+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Quantum numbers and shapes of orbitals

Which of the following combination of statements is true regarding the interpretation of the atomic orbitals?
(A) An electron in an orbital of high angular momentum stays away from the nucleus than an electron in the orbital of lower angular momentum.
(B) For a given value of the principal quantum number, the size of the orbit is inversely proportional to the azimuthal quantum number.
(C) According to wave mechanics, the ground state angular momentum is equal to h2π\frac{h}{2\pi}.
(D) The plot of ψ\psi Vs rr for various azimuthal quantum numbers, shows peak shifting towards higher rr value.

SOLUTION

First, recall that in quantum mechanics four quantum numbers -n, l, ml, msn,\,l,\,m_l,\,m_s- describe an electron in an atom. Out of these, the principal quantum number nn mainly controls the general size (average distance from the nucleus), while the azimuthal or orbital angular-momentum quantum number ll decides the shape and the angular momentum of the orbital.

For the magnitude of orbital angular momentum, wave mechanics gives the exact formula

L=l(l+1) ℏ,L=\sqrt{l(l+1)}\,\hbar,

where ℏ=h2π\hbar=\dfrac{h}{2\pi} is the reduced Planck constant. We now examine each given statement in the light of this accepted theory.

Examining statement (A): “An electron in an orbital of high angular momentum stays away from the nucleus than an electron in the orbital of lower angular momentum.”

When ll is larger (for the same nn) the centrifugal term in the Schrödinger radial equation, l(l+1)ℏ22mr2,\dfrac{l(l+1)\hbar^{2}}{2mr^{2}}, becomes larger. This term pushes the electron probability density outward; equivalently, the most probable radius rmpr_{mp} increases with ll. Therefore electrons in p, d … orbitals (larger ll) are on the average farther from the nucleus than electrons in an s orbital (l=0l=0). So statement (A) is true.

Examining statement (B): “For a given value of the principal quantum number, the size of the orbit is inversely proportional to the azimuthal quantum number.”

As just reasoned, when ll increases, rmpr_{mp} also increases; there is no inverse proportionality such as r∝1lr\propto\dfrac1l. Instead, the trend is the opposite (direct, not inverse). Hence statement (B) is false.

Examining statement (C): “According to wave mechanics, the ground-state angular momentum is equal to h2π\dfrac{h}{2\pi}.”

In the ground state of hydrogen (and hydrogen-like atoms) we have n=1n=1 and, by quantum rules, l=0l=0. Substituting l=0l=0 in the angular-momentum formula gives

L=0(0+1) ℏ=0.L=\sqrt{0(0+1)}\,\hbar=0.

Thus wave mechanics predicts zero orbital angular momentum for the ground state, not ℏ=h2π\hbar=\dfrac{h}{2\pi}. The quoted value corresponds to the Bohr model, not to the Schrödinger description. Therefore statement (C) is false.

Examining statement (D): “The plot of ψ\psi vs rr for various azimuthal quantum numbers shows peak shifting towards higher rr value.”

For a fixed principal quantum number nn, increasing ll moves the maximum of the radial wave function Rnl(r)R_{nl}(r) outward, as discussed for (A). Hence the peak of ψ\psi (or of the radial probability distribution) indeed shifts toward a larger rr. Statement (D) is true.

Combining our results:

(A) = True,\text{(A) = True}, (B) = False,\text{(B) = False}, (C) = False,\text{(C) = False}, (D) = True.\text{(D) = True}.

The only option that lists statements (A) and (D) together is Option 4.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Quantum numbers and shapes of orbitals. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicQuantum numbers and shapes of orbitals
TypeMultiple choice