RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Quantum mechanical model, wave function and probability

The correct statement about probability density (except at infinite distance from nucleus) is:

SOLUTION

We begin with the definition of probability density in quantum mechanics. For any hydrogen-like orbital, the probability density at a point in space is given by the square of the magnitude of the wave-function:

Probability density=∣Ψn,l,m(r,θ,ϕ)∣2.\text{Probability density}=|\Psi_{n,l,m}(r,\theta,\phi)|^{2}.

Because we are squaring an absolute value, we immediately obtain the inequality

∣Ψn,l,m∣2  ≥  0,|\Psi_{n,l,m}|^{2}\;\ge\;0,

so the probability density can never be negative at any finite point in space.

Next we recall the nodal rules for hydrogen-like orbitals. The total number of nodes possessed by an orbital with quantum numbers nn and ll is n−1.n-1. These nodes are of two kinds:

• Radial (spherical) nodes, counted by the well-known formula

Number of radial nodes=n−l−1,\text{Number of radial nodes}=n-l-1,

• Angular (planar/conical) nodes, whose number equals l.l. At every node the wave-function Ψ\Psi changes sign, so its value is exactly zero; consequently the probability density, being ∣Ψ∣2,|\Psi|^{2}, is also zero at that position.

We now examine each option one by one, using the above facts.

Option A: 1s orbital has n=1,  l=0.n=1,\;l=0. The number of radial nodes is 1−0−1=0,1-0-1 = 0, and the number of angular nodes is 0.0. Thus, except at r→∞,r\to\infty, the wave-function is never zero, so the probability density is never zero within finite space. Hence Option A is incorrect.

Option B: We have already proved that ∣Ψ∣2|\Psi|^{2} can never be negative, because it is a squared modulus. Therefore probability density cannot be negative for a 2p orbital or for any other orbital. Option B is incorrect.

Option C: 3p orbital has n=3,  l=1.n=3,\;l=1. First we compute the radial nodes: n−l−1=3−1−1=1.n-l-1 = 3-1-1 = 1. In addition, because l=1,l=1, there is 11 angular node (a nodal plane). Both the radial node and the angular node are genuine points (or surfaces) where Ψ=0,\Psi=0, so the probability density ∣Ψ∣2|\Psi|^{2} is zero there. Thus, for a 3p orbital, the probability density can indeed be zero at finite distances from the nucleus. Option C is correct.

Option D: 2s orbital has n=2,  l=0.n=2,\;l=0. The number of radial nodes is 2−0−1=1,2-0-1 = 1, so there exists a spherical surface inside which Ψ=0,\Psi=0, making the probability density zero on that surface. Therefore the statement that it can “never be zero” is false, and Option D is incorrect.

Out of the four alternatives, only Option C survives careful scrutiny.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Quantum mechanical model, wave function and probability. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicQuantum mechanical model, wave function and probability
TypeMultiple choice