RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2005TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2005 Chemistry question — Radial and angular nodes and orbital energies

In a multi-electron atom, which of the following orbitals described by the three quantum numbers will have the same energy in the absence of magnetic acid and electric fields? (a) n=1,l=0,m=0n = 1, l = 0, m = 0 (b) n=2,l=0,m=0n = 2, l = 0, m = 0 (c) n=2,l=1,m=1n = 2, l = 1, m = 1 (d) n=3,l=2,m=1n = 3, l = 2, m = 1 (e) n=3,l=2,m=0n = 3, l = 2, m = 0

SOLUTION

For a hydrogen atom the energy of an orbital depends only on the principal quantum number nn, so all the orbitals having the same nn are degenerate. In a multi-electron atom the electron-electron repulsions break this degeneracy: the energy of an orbital is now a function of both nn and the azimuthal quantum number ll (as summarised by the n+ln+l rule).

However, in the absence of any external magnetic or electric field the energy still does not depend on the magnetic quantum number mm, because all the different orientations of a given subshell experience the same electrostatic environment inside the atom. Therefore:

• Orbitals with the same pair (n,l)(n,l) but different mm values remain degenerate.
• Orbitals that differ in either nn or ll will, in general, have different energies in a multi-electron atom.

Let us examine the list:

(a) n=1,  l=0,  m=0n=1,\; l=0,\; m=0 — a 1s orbital
(b) n=2,  l=0,  m=0n=2,\; l=0,\; m=0 — a 2s orbital
(c) n=2,  l=1,  m=1n=2,\; l=1,\; m=1 — a 2p orbital
(d) n=3,  l=2,  m=1n=3,\; l=2,\; m=1 — a 3d orbital (one particular orientation)
(e) n=3,  l=2,  m=0n=3,\; l=2,\; m=0 — the same 3d subshell but a different orientation

Only (d) and (e) share the identical quantum numbers n=3n=3 and l=2l=2; they differ only in mm. Hence they possess the same energy in a multi-electron atom when no external fields are applied. All the other pairs differ either in nn or in ll, so their energies are different.

Therefore the orbitals that have the same energy are (d) and (e).

Option D which is: (d) and (e)

Tagged Radial and angular nodes and orbital energies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicRadial and angular nodes and orbital energies
TypeMultiple choice