RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Radial and angular nodes and orbital energies

The isoelectronic set of ions is:

SOLUTION

We recall that species are said to be isoelectronic when each of them possesses exactly the same total number of electrons.

For any neutral atom the number of electrons equals its atomic number ZZ. When the species is an ion, we adjust this count as follows:

For a cation having charge +n+n, the ion has lost nn electrons, so

electrons in cation=Z−n.\text{electrons in cation}=Z-n.

For an anion carrying charge −n-n, the ion has gained nn electrons, therefore

electrons in anion=Z+n.\text{electrons in anion}=Z+n.

Now we write the atomic numbers of all the elements that appear in the four options:

Z(Li)=3,Z(N)=7,Z(O)=8,Z(F)=9,Z(Na)=11,Z(Mg)=12.\begin{aligned} Z(\text{Li})&=3,\\ Z(\text{N}) &=7,\\ Z(\text{O}) &=8,\\ Z(\text{F}) &=9,\\ Z(\text{Na})&=11,\\ Z(\text{Mg})&=12. \end{aligned}

Using the above relationships we calculate the electron count for every ion mentioned in the options:

Li+:3−1=2,N3−:7+3=10,O2−:8+2=10,F−:9+1=10,Na+:11−1=10,Mg2+:12−2=10.\begin{aligned} \text{Li}^+ &: 3-1=2,\\[2pt] \text{N}^{3-}&: 7+3=10,\\[2pt] \text{O}^{2-}&: 8+2=10,\\[2pt] \text{F}^- &: 9+1=10,\\[2pt] \text{Na}^+ &: 11-1=10,\\[2pt] \text{Mg}^{2+}&: 12-2=10. \end{aligned}

With these values in hand we examine each option one by one.

Option A: F−(10),  Li+(2),  Na+(10),  Mg2+(10)\text{F}^- (10),\; \text{Li}^+ (2),\; \text{Na}^+ (10),\; \text{Mg}^{2+} (10) — the value 22 for Li+\text{Li}^+ breaks the equality, so the set is not isoelectronic.

Option B: N3−(10),  Li+(2),  Mg2+(10),  O2−(10)\text{N}^{3-} (10),\; \text{Li}^+ (2),\; \text{Mg}^{2+} (10),\; \text{O}^{2-} (10) — again the 22 electrons of Li+\text{Li}^+ cause a mismatch.

Option C: N3−(10),  O2−(10),  F−(10),  Na+(10)\text{N}^{3-} (10),\; \text{O}^{2-} (10),\; \text{F}^- (10),\; \text{Na}^+ (10) — every ion here has exactly 1010 electrons, so all four are indeed isoelectronic.

Option D: Li+(2),  Na+(10),  O2−(10),  F−(10)\text{Li}^+ (2),\; \text{Na}^+ (10),\; \text{O}^{2-} (10),\; \text{F}^- (10) — the presence of Li+\text{Li}^+ with only 22 electrons destroys the uniformity.

Clearly, only Option C satisfies the requirement that each species in the list contain the same number of electrons.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Radial and angular nodes and orbital energies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicRadial and angular nodes and orbital energies
TypeMultiple choice