Among the following structures, which will show the most stable enamine formation? (Where Me is )
For any carbonyl compound the sequence for enamine formation is : (1) nucleophilic addition of a secondary amine on the carbon, (2) proton transfers, and (3) loss of water accompanied by removal of an -hydrogen to give the C=C-N system. The position of equilibrium
depends on the stability of the enamine that is produced. A more stable enamine pulls the equilibrium to the right and therefore “forms most readily”. The stability of an enamine is governed by the same factors that stabilise ordinary alkenes:
• greater alkyl substitution on the C=C bond (hyperconjugation and +I effect)
• conjugation of the C=C bond with another -system (aromatic ring, C=C, C≡C, etc.)
All alkyl groups are simple methyl/ethyl groups, so the resulting C=C bond is only modestly substituted and not conjugated with any other -system.
Case B:The situation is similar to Case A; no extra substitution and no conjugation.
Case C:The carbonyl carbon is directly attached to a phenyl ring. When the -proton is removed, the resulting C=C bond becomes
This double bond is in conjugation with the benzene ring. Resonance delocalises the enamine’s double bond into the aromatic system, giving several resonance contributors such as
Conjugation with the aromatic ring therefore provides a large extra stabilisation on top of the normal alkyl-substitution stabilisation.
Case D:Here again the C=C bond produced in the enamine is only alkyl-substituted and not conjugated with any extended -system.
Comparing all four cases, the enamine derived from Case C is the only one that enjoys resonance conjugation with an aromatic ring in addition to normal alkyl substitution. That additional delocalisation lowers its energy the most, so Case C gives the most stable enamine and therefore shows the easiest / most favourable enamine formation.
Hence the correct choice is:
Option C which is: the carbonyl compound having the phenyl ring directly attached to the carbonyl carbon.
Tagged Reactions and tests of amines. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.