RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2021 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question — Equilibrium of rigid bodies and toppling

One end of a horizontal uniform beam of weight 𝑊 and length 𝐿 is hinged on a vertical wall at point O and its other end is supported by a light inextensible rope. The other end of the rope is fixed at point Q, at a height 𝐿 above the hinge at point O. A block of weight αW\alpha W is attached at the point P of the beam, as shown in the figure (not to scale). The rope can sustain a maximum tension of (222\sqrt{2})W. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

Figure for JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question on Equilibrium of rigid bodies and toppling
SOLUTION

The beam OA is uniform, horizontal and of length LL. It is hinged at the wall at OO.
The light, inextensible rope is tied at the free end AA of the beam and at the point QQ which is vertically above OO by the same distance LL.
Hence the rope is of length L2+L2=L2\sqrt{L^{2}+L^{2}} = L\sqrt{2} and it makes an angle of 45∘45^{\circ} with both the horizontal and the vertical.

Let

• WW = weight of the beam (acts at its mid-point L/2L/2 from the hinge).
• αW\alpha W = weight of the block hung at the point PP situated at a distance xx from the hinge.
• TT = tension in the rope.
• HH = horizontal component of the hinge reaction, taken positive towards the right (along +x).
• VV = vertical component of the hinge reaction, taken positive upwards (along +y).

Step 1 : Equilibrium of forces

Horizontal balance: H+(−Tcos⁡45∘)=0    ⟹    H=T2−(1)H + \big(-T\cos 45^{\circ}\big)=0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; H=\dfrac{T}{\sqrt{2}} \quad -(1)

Vertical balance: V+Tsin⁡45∘−W−αW=0    ⟹    V=W(1+α)−T2−(2)V + T\sin 45^{\circ} -W-\alpha W =0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; V = W(1+\alpha)-\dfrac{T}{\sqrt{2}} \quad -(2)

Step 2 : Equilibrium of moments about the hinge O (anticlockwise positive)

The moment of the tension about OO is produced by the perpendicular distance LL of its line of action: τT=+ L  Tsin⁡45∘=L T2.\tau_{T}=+\,L\;T\sin 45^{\circ}= \dfrac{L\,T}{\sqrt{2}}. The clockwise moments due to the two weights are

τW=− W(L2),ταW=− αW x.\tau_{W}= -\,W\left(\dfrac{L}{2}\right), \qquad \tau_{\alpha W}= -\,\alpha W\,x.

Setting the net moment equal to zero gives

L T2−W(L2)−αWx=0    ⟹    T=2W ⁣(12+α xL)−(3)\dfrac{L\,T}{\sqrt{2}} - W\left(\dfrac{L}{2}\right) - \alpha W x = 0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; T = \sqrt{2}W\!\left(\dfrac12 + \alpha\,\dfrac{x}{L}\right) \quad -(3)

Step 3 : Vertical reaction

Substituting the value of T/2T/\sqrt{2} from (3) into (2):

T2=W ⁣(12+α xL)\dfrac{T}{\sqrt{2}} = W\!\left(\dfrac12 + \alpha\,\dfrac{x}{L}\right)

⟹    V=W ⁣[1+α−12−α xL]=W ⁣[12+α ⁣(1−xL)]−(4)\Longrightarrow\;\; V = W\!\left[1+\alpha-\dfrac12 - \alpha\,\dfrac{x}{L}\right] = W\!\left[\dfrac12 + \alpha\!\left(1-\dfrac{x}{L}\right)\right] \quad -(4)

The quantity α\alpha will disappear from expression (4) only when the bracket multiplying it is zero, i.e.

1−xL=0⟹x=L.1-\dfrac{x}{L}=0 \Longrightarrow x = L.

This means the block must be hung from the extreme end AA of the beam (which is indeed the position of point PP in the figure). With this condition one obtains

V=W2,V = \dfrac{W}{2},

which is a constant, completely independent of the value of α\alpha. Hence statement A is correct.

Step 4 : Verifying the remaining statements

Statement B

Putting x=Lx=L and α=0.5\alpha =0.5 in (3):

T=2W ⁣(12+0.5)=2W.T = \sqrt{2}W\!\left(\dfrac12 + 0.5\right)= \sqrt{2}W.

Therefore from (1)

H=T2=W.H = \dfrac{T}{\sqrt{2}} = W.

The horizontal reaction, however, acts towards the right (positive) while the numerical value quoted in the option carries no sign. Since direction is an essential part of a vector component, the statement is not accepted as correct.

Statement C

For α=0.5\alpha =0.5 we have already obtained T=2W≈1.414 WT=\sqrt{2}W\approx1.414\,W, not 2W2W. Hence statement C is wrong.

Statement D

The rope can withstand a maximum tension Tmax=22 WT_{\text{max}}=2\sqrt{2}\,W. From (3) with x=Lx=L, the tension is

T=2W ⁣(12+α).T = \sqrt{2}W\!\left(\dfrac12+\alpha\right).

Equating T=TmaxT=T_{\text{max}} gives

2W ⁣(12+α)=22W    ⟹    α=1.5.\sqrt{2}W\!\left(\dfrac12+\alpha\right)=2\sqrt{2}W \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \alpha = 1.5. For α=1.5\alpha =1.5 the rope is exactly at its limiting tension; it will start snapping the instant α\alpha exceeds this value, i.e. for α≥1.5\alpha \ge 1.5. Because the option claims breakage only when α>1.5\alpha > 1.5 (excluding the equality case), it is not strictly correct.

Thus, the only statement that is wholly correct is

Option A which states: “The vertical component of reaction force at O does not depend on α\alpha.”

Tagged Equilibrium of rigid bodies and toppling. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicEquilibrium of rigid bodies and toppling
TypeMultiple correct