RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2021 · PAPER 1+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question — Rolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces

A horizontal force 𝐹 is applied at the center of mass of a cylindrical object of mass 𝑚 and radius 𝑅, perpendicular to its axis as shown in the figure. The coefficient of friction between the object and the ground is μ\mu. The center of mass of the object has an acceleration 𝑎. The acceleration due to gravity is 𝑔. Given that the object rolls without slipping, which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

Figure for JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question on Rolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces
SOLUTION

The forces acting on the cylindrical object are
  • the applied horizontal force FF at its centre of mass (to the right),
  • the static frictional force ff at the point of contact with the ground (to the left, because it must oppose the relative motion that would otherwise occur),
  • the weight mgmg (downward) and the normal reaction NN (upward).
Only FF and ff have horizontal components, so the vertical forces do not enter the following calculations.

1. Translational motion of the centre of mass
Using Newton’s second law along the horizontal direction,

F−f=ma−(1)F - f = m a \quad -(1)

where aa is the linear acceleration of the centre of mass.

2. Rotational motion about the centre of mass
The only horizontal force that produces a torque about the centre of mass is the frictional force (the line of action of FF passes through the centre, so it gives no torque).
If the cylinder rolls without slipping, the angular acceleration α\alpha is related to aa by

a=Rα−(2)a = R\alpha \quad -(2)

Taking clockwise as positive, the torque equation is

fR=Iα−(3)fR = I \alpha \quad -(3)

The moment of inertia of a general cylinder can be written as

I=k mR2I = k\,mR^{2}

where
  • k=12k = \tfrac12 for a solid cylinder,
  • k=1k = 1 for a thin-walled hollow cylinder.

Substituting II and using (2) in (3):

fR=k mR2(aR)    ⟹    f=k m a−(4)fR = k\,mR^{2}\Bigl(\frac{a}{R}\Bigr) \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; f = k\,m\,a \quad -(4)

3. Eliminating the frictional force
Insert (4) in the translational equation (1):

F−k m a=m aF - k\,m\,a = m\,a
⟹  F=m a (1+k)\Longrightarrow\; F = m\,a\,(1+k)
a=Fm (1+k)−(5)\boxed{a = \dfrac{F}{m\,(1+k)}} \quad -(5)

Case 1: Solid cylinder  (k=12k=\tfrac12)
From (5), a=Fm (1+12)=2F3ma = \dfrac{F}{m\,(1+\tfrac12)} = \dfrac{2F}{3m}.

Case 2: Thin-walled hollow cylinder  (k=1k = 1)
From (5), a=Fm (1+1)=F2ma = \dfrac{F}{m\,(1+1)} = \dfrac{F}{2m}.

4. Condition for rolling without slipping
Static friction must not exceed its limiting value:

∣f∣≤μmg−(6)|f| \le \mu m g \quad -(6)

With f=kmaf = k m a from (4), inequality (6) gives

kma≤μmg    ⟹    a≤μgk−(7)k m a \le \mu m g \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; a \le \frac{\mu g}{k} \quad -(7)

Maximum acceleration for a solid cylinder
For a solid cylinder, k=12k = \tfrac12, so (7) becomes

amax=μg12=2μga_{\text{max}} = \frac{\mu g}{\tfrac12} = 2\mu g

This is the highest acceleration possible while maintaining rolling without slipping; it is achieved when the static friction reaches its limiting value f=μmgf = \mu m g.

5. Verification of the given statements

Option A: “For the same FF, the value of aa does not depend on whether the cylinder is solid or hollow.”
Equation (5) shows a=F/[m(1+k)]a = F/[m(1+k)], which does depend on kk. Therefore, Option A is incorrect.

Option B: “For a solid cylinder, the maximum possible value of aa is 2μg2\mu g.”
Derived above: amax=2μga_{\text{max}} = 2\mu g. Option B is correct.

Option C: “The magnitude of the frictional force on the object due to the ground is always μmg\mu mg.”
Actual friction is f=kmaf = k m a from (4), and only equals μmg\mu mg when the limiting condition is reached; otherwise it is smaller. Hence Option C is incorrect.

Option D: “For a thin-walled hollow cylinder, a=F2ma = \dfrac{F}{2m}.”
Equation (5) gives a=F/(2m)a = F/(2m) for k=1k=1, but this holds only if rolling without slipping is possible, i.e. if f≤μmgf \le \mu m g. When FF is so large that ff would exceed this limit, slipping occurs and (5) no longer applies. Since the statement does not mention this restriction, it is not always true. Option D is therefore incorrect.

Conclusion
Only Option B is correct.

Final answer: Option B which is: For a solid cylinder, the maximum possible value of aa is 2μg2 \mu g.

Tagged Rolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces
TypeMultiple correct