RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2016 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2016 Physics question — Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies

Two thin circular discs of mass m and 4m, having radii of a and 2a, respectively, are rigidly fixed by a mass less, rigid rod of length l=2424al = 24\sqrt{24} a through their centers. This assembly is laid on a firm and flat surface, and set rolling without slipping on the surface so that the angular speed about the axis of the rod is ω\omega. The angular momentum of the entire assembly about the point ‘O’ is L→\overrightarrow{L} (see the figure). Which of the following statement(s) is(are) true?

Figure for JEE Advanced 2016 Physics question on Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies
SOLUTION

Key idea: The rolling assembly acts like a cone with its apex at O. Its total angular velocity lies along the line of contact on the ground. Split that into the spin ω\omega about the rod and a precession Ω\Omega about zz.

Take l=24 al = \sqrt{24}\,a (the 242424\sqrt{24} in the statement appears to be a typo). The rod makes angle α\alpha with the ground, where sin⁡α=al2+a2=a5a=15\sin\alpha = \dfrac{a}{\sqrt{l^2 + a^2}} = \dfrac{a}{5a} = \dfrac15.

  1. No slipping means the contact line is the instantaneous axis, which is horizontal. So ω e^rod+Ω z^  is horizontal⇒ωsin⁡α=Ω⇒Ω=ω5\omega\,\hat e_{rod} + \Omega\,\hat z \ \text{ is horizontal} \Rightarrow \omega\sin\alpha = \Omega \Rightarrow \Omega = \frac{\omega}{5} The centre of mass circles the z-axis at ω/5\omega/5, so (A) is true.
  2. The centre of mass is at ml+4m(2l)5m=9l5\dfrac{m l + 4m(2l)}{5m} = \dfrac{9l}{5} from O. Its angular momentum about O is 5m(9l5)2Ωcos⁡α=81⋅2425 ma2ω≈77.8 ma2ω5m\left(\frac{9l}{5}\right)^2\Omega\cos\alpha = \frac{81\cdot24}{25}\,ma^2\omega \approx 77.8\,ma^2\omega This is not 81 ma2ω81\,ma^2\omega, so (B) is false.
  3. About the centre of mass, the precession adds to the spin term 172ma2ω\frac{17}{2}ma^2\omega (from 12ma2+12(4m)(2a)2\frac12 ma^2 + \frac12(4m)(2a)^2), so (C) is false.
  4. Computing LzL_z exactly from the inertia tensor about O with the full angular velocity gives about 77.5 ma2ω77.5\,ma^2\omega, not 55 ma2ω55\,ma^2\omega, so (D) is not supported.

Answer: (A)

Tagged Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicAngular momentum of particles and rigid bodies
TypeMultiple correct