RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2024 · PAPER 1+3 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2024 Physics question — Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth

A light ray is incident on the surface of a sphere of refractive index nn at an angle of incidence θ0\theta_0. The ray partially refracts into the sphere with angle of refraction ϕ0\phi_0 and then partly reflects from the back surface. The reflected ray then emerges out of the sphere after a partial refraction. The total angle of deviation of the emergent ray with respect to the incident ray is α\alpha. Match the quantities mentioned in List-I with their values in List-II and choose the correct option.

List-IList-II
(P)If n=2n = 2 and α=180°\alpha = 180°, then all the possible values of θ0\theta_0 will be(1)30°30° and 0°0°
(Q)If n=3n = \sqrt{3} and α=180°\alpha = 180°, then all the possible values of θ0\theta_0 will be(2)60°60° and 0°0°
(R)If n=3n = \sqrt{3} and α=180°\alpha = 180°, then all the possible values of ϕ0\phi_0 will be(3)45°45° and 0°0°
(S)If n=2n = \sqrt{2} and θ0=45°\theta_0 = 45°, then all the possible values of α\alpha will be(4)150°150°
(5)0°0°
SOLUTION

The ray suffers two refractions (at the first and the last surface) and one total internal reflection (at the back surface).
Let the angle of incidence be θ0\theta_0 (in air) and the corresponding angle of refraction inside the sphere be ϕ0\phi_0.
From Snell’s law (air to glass):

sin⁡θ0=nsin⁡ϕ0−(1)\sin \theta_0 = n \sin \phi_0 \qquad -(1)

For a spherical drop the total deviation produced by “refraction-reflection-refraction’’ is a standard result (used while studying rainbows):

α  =  180∘  +  2θ0  −  4ϕ0−(2)\alpha \;=\; 180^\circ \;+\; 2\theta_0 \;-\; 4\phi_0 \qquad -(2)

Using (1)(1) and (2)(2) we answer each item.

Case P (n = 2 ,  α = 180°)

Putting in (2):  180∘=180∘+2θ0−4ϕ0⟹θ0=2ϕ0.(2):\; 180^\circ = 180^\circ + 2\theta_0 - 4\phi_0 \Longrightarrow \theta_0 = 2\phi_0. Substituting in (1):  sin⁡(2ϕ0)=2sin⁡ϕ0.(1):\; \sin(2\phi_0) = 2\sin\phi_0. Since sin⁡(2ϕ0)=2sin⁡ϕ0cos⁡ϕ0,\sin(2\phi_0)=2\sin\phi_0\cos\phi_0, we get 2sin⁡ϕ0cos⁡ϕ0=2sin⁡ϕ0.2\sin\phi_0\cos\phi_0 = 2\sin\phi_0. Either sin⁡ϕ0=0\sin\phi_0 = 0 or cos⁡ϕ0=1.\cos\phi_0 = 1. Both give ϕ0=0∘⟹θ0=0∘.\phi_0 = 0^\circ \Longrightarrow \theta_0 = 0^\circ. Hence all possible θ0\theta_0 values = 0∘0^\circ (List-II →\rightarrow 5).

Case Q (n = √3 ,  α = 180°)

Again θ0=2ϕ0.\theta_0 = 2\phi_0. Put in (1):  sin⁡(2ϕ0)=3 sin⁡ϕ0.(1):\; \sin(2\phi_0) = \sqrt{3}\,\sin\phi_0. 2sin⁡ϕ0cos⁡ϕ0=3 sin⁡ϕ0  ⟹  2cos⁡ϕ0=3.2\sin\phi_0\cos\phi_0 = \sqrt{3}\,\sin\phi_0 \; \Longrightarrow\; 2\cos\phi_0 = \sqrt{3}. So cos⁡ϕ0=32⟹ϕ0=30∘.\cos\phi_0 = \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \Longrightarrow \phi_0 = 30^\circ. Hence θ0=2ϕ0=60∘.\theta_0 = 2\phi_0 = 60^\circ. The trivial solution ϕ0=0∘,  θ0=0∘\phi_0 = 0^\circ,\; \theta_0 = 0^\circ also satisfies both equations. Thus all possible θ0\theta_0 values = 60∘60^\circ and 0∘0^\circ (List-II →\rightarrow 2).

Case R (n = √3 ,  α = 180°)

The two ϕ0\phi_0 values found above are 30∘30^\circ and 0∘0^\circ (List-II →\rightarrow 1).

Case S (n = √2 ,  θ0 = 45°)

From (1):  sin⁡45∘=2 sin⁡ϕ0  ⟹  12=2 sin⁡ϕ0  ⟹  sin⁡ϕ0=12  ⟹  ϕ0=30∘.(1):\; \sin45^\circ = \sqrt{2}\,\sin\phi_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}} = \sqrt{2}\,\sin\phi_0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \sin\phi_0 = \dfrac{1}{2} \;\Longrightarrow\; \phi_0 = 30^\circ. Now use (2):  α=180∘+2(45∘)−4(30∘)=180∘+90∘−120∘=150∘.(2):\; \alpha = 180^\circ + 2(45^\circ) - 4(30^\circ) = 180^\circ + 90^\circ - 120^\circ = 150^\circ. Thus all possible α\alpha values = 150∘150^\circ (List-II →\rightarrow 4).

Collecting the matches:
P →\rightarrow 5,  Q →\rightarrow 2,  R →\rightarrow 1,  S →\rightarrow 4.

Hence the correct option is Option A: P →\rightarrow 5; Q →\rightarrow 2; R →\rightarrow 1; S →\rightarrow 4.

Tagged Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRefraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth
TypeMultiple choice