RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2021 · PAPER 1+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question — Prism: deviation and dispersion

A wide slab consisting of two media of refractive indices n1n_1 and n2n_2 is placed in air as shown in the figure. A ray of light is incident from medium n1n_1 to n2n_2 at an angle θ\theta, where sin⁡θ\sin \theta is slightly larger than 1n1\frac{1}{n_1}. Take refractive index of air as 1. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

Figure for JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question on Prism: deviation and dispersion
SOLUTION

Let the refractive indices be arranged as
air (top, n=1n = 1)  |  medium n1n_1  |  medium n2n_2  |  air (bottom, n=1n = 1).

The ray starts inside n1n_1 and strikes the n1 ⁣− ⁣n2n_1\!-\!n_2 interface at an angle θ\theta that satisfies

sin⁡θ=1n1+ε,\sin\theta = \frac{1}{n_1} + \varepsilon,

where ε>0\varepsilon \gt 0 is a very small positive number. Because sin⁡θ>1n1\sin\theta \gt \dfrac{1}{n_1}, the ray would have suffered total internal reflection (TIR) if the medium outside n1n_1 had been air. We now examine what really happens in the presence of the n2n_2 layer.

Step 1: Refraction at the n1 ⁣− ⁣n2n_1\!-\!n_2 interface
Applying Snell’s law

n1sin⁡θ=n2sin⁡ϕ⟹sin⁡ϕ=n1n2sin⁡θ.n_1\sin\theta = n_2\sin\phi \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \sin\phi = \frac{n_1}{n_2}\sin\theta.

Substituting sin⁡θ=1n1+ε\sin\theta = \dfrac{1}{n_1} + \varepsilon gives

sin⁡ϕ=1n2+n1n2 ε.−(1)\sin\phi = \frac{1}{n_2} + \frac{n_1}{n_2}\,\varepsilon. \qquad -(1)

The second term in (1) is positive, so

sin⁡ϕ>1n2.\sin\phi \gt \frac{1}{n_2}.

Step 2: Incidence at the n2 ⁣− ⁣airn_2\!-\!{\rm air} interface
The critical angle for the n2 ⁣− ⁣airn_2\!-\!{\rm air} interface is defined by sin⁡ϕc=1n2.\sin\phi_c = \frac{1}{n_2}. Because sin⁡ϕ>1n2\sin\phi \gt \dfrac{1}{n_2} from (1), the ray is definitely above the critical angle and therefore undergoes total internal reflection at the lower surface. After reflection, it travels upward in medium n2n_2 with the same angle ϕ\phi.

Step 3: Returning to the n2 ⁣− ⁣n1n_2\!-\!n_1 interface
When the ray coming from n2n_2 meets the n2 ⁣− ⁣n1n_2\!-\!n_1 boundary, its angle of incidence is again ϕ\phi. Whether n2n_2 is larger, equal to, or smaller than n1n_1, Snell’s law gives

n2sin⁡ϕ=n1sin⁡θ,n_2\sin\phi = n_1\sin\theta,

which has a real solution for sin⁡θ\sin\theta because sin⁡θ≤1\sin\theta \le 1. Therefore total internal reflection cannot occur here; the ray always refracts back into medium n1n_1.

Step 4: Meeting the upper n1 ⁣− ⁣airn_1\!-\!{\rm air} interface
Inside n1n_1 the ray still makes the same angle θ\theta with the normal. Since sin⁡θ=1n1+ε>1n1,\sin\theta = \dfrac{1}{n_1} + \varepsilon \gt \dfrac{1}{n_1}, the ray is again above the critical angle for the n1 ⁣− ⁣airn_1\!-\!{\rm air} surface and is totally internally reflected. Hence it remains trapped inside the slab, always coming back into the n1n_1 region.

Now check each statement:

Option A: If n2=n1n_2 = n_1 the two internal media are identical, but the analysis above still shows TIR at the lower air surface and again at the upper air surface. The ray never reaches air. False.

Option B: For n2<n1n_2 \lt n_1, all steps above remain valid (because (1) was derived without assuming any ordering of n1,n2n_1,n_2). The ray finally returns to medium n1n_1. True.

Option C: For n2>n1n_2 \gt n_1 the same conclusion follows; the ray refracts back into n1n_1 after the lower TIR and is again reflected at the top surface. True.

Option D: If n2=1n_2 = 1, the first interface itself is n1 ⁣− ⁣airn_1\!-\!{\rm air}. Because sin⁡θ>1n1\sin\theta \gt \dfrac{1}{n_1}, the ray is totally internally reflected immediately, i.e. it stays in n1n_1. True.

Hence the correct statements are:
Option B, Option C and Option D.

Final Answer: Option B, Option C, Option D

Tagged Prism: deviation and dispersion. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicPrism: deviation and dispersion
TypeMultiple correct