JEE Advanced 2025 Physics question — Electric flux and Gauss's law
Two co-axial conducting cylinders of same length ℓ with radii 2R and 2R are kept, as shown in Fig. 1. The charge on the inner cylinder is Q and the outer cylinder is grounded. The annular region between the cylinders is filled with a material of dielectric constant κ=5. Consider an imaginary plane of the same length ℓ at a distance R from the common axis of the cylinders. This plane is parallel to the axis of the cylinders. The cross-sectional view of this arrangement is shown in Fig. 2. Ignoring edge effects, the flux of the electric field through the plane is (ϵ0 is the permittivity of free space):
SOLUTION
Let the inner and outer conducting cylinders be coaxial with the common z-axis.
Radius of inner cylinder : 2R
Radius of outer cylinder : 2R
Free charge on inner cylinder : Q (uniformly distributed along its length ℓ)
Surface charge density per unit length (line charge) : λ=ℓQ.
The space between the two cylinders is filled with a dielectric of relative permittivity κ=5.
The outer cylinder is earthed, hence the electric field exists only in the dielectric region 2R≤r≤2R and is purely radial.
Electric field inside the dielectric
Take a cylindrical Gaussian surface of radius r (with 2R≤r≤2R) and length ℓ. Using Gauss’s law in dielectrics,
∮D⋅dA=Qfree enclosed⟹D(2πrℓ)=λℓ⇒D=2πrλ.
Since D=κε0E, we get
E(r)=2πκε0rλ,E=E(r)r^.
(Inside r<2R the electric field is zero.)
The required open surface
We need the electric flux through a plane that
is parallel to the axis, of length ℓ,
is at a perpendicular distance R from the axis (take it as the plane x=R).
In the cross-section (the xy-plane) this surface appears as the straight line x=R.
Only the part of this line lying in the dielectric region (r≥2R) contributes to flux.
Limits of the contributing strip on the plane
Put x=R and write r=x2+y2=R2+y2.
Inner boundary: r=2R⇒y=±R
Outer boundary: r=2R⇒y=±3R
Hence the dielectric occupies y∈[−3R,−R]∪[R,3R] on the plane.
Element of area and flux through it
For a strip of width dy on this plane, area element
dA=ℓdy.
The unit normal to the plane is n^=x^ (along +x), while the electric field is radial, so the cosine of the angle between E and n^ equals rx=rR.
Therefore, the differential flux is