JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Relation between field and potential, equipotential surfaces
A disk of radius R with uniform positive charge density σ is placed on the xy plane with its center at the origin. The Coulomb potential along the z-axis is
V(z)=2ϵ0σ(R2+z2−z)
A particle of positive charge q is placed initially at rest at a point on the z axis with z=z0 and z0>0. In addition to the Coulomb force, the particle experiences a vertical force F=−ck^ with c>0. Let β=qσ2cϵ0. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?
SOLUTION
The electrostatic potential produced by the charged disk is given as V(z)=2ϵ0σ(R2+z2−z).
For a particle of charge q the corresponding electrostatic potential energy is UC(z)=qV(z)=2ϵ0qσ(R2+z2−z).
The particle is also acted upon by a constant downward force F=−ck^.
Since Fz=−dzdUg=−c, the mechanical potential energy associated with this force is
Ug(z)=cz (we take Ug(0)=0).
Hence the total potential energy of the particle is U(z)=UC(z)+Ug(z)=2ϵ0qσ(R2+z2−z)+cz.
Put
α=2ϵ0qσ,β=qσ2cϵ0=αc(β>0).
Then
U(z)=α[R2+z2−z+βz]=α[R2+z2+(β−1)z].
The motion is one-dimensional along the z-axis.
Because only conservative forces act, the mechanical energy
E=U(z)+K is conserved.
At the instant t=0 the particle is released from rest at z=z0, so
E=U(z0).
If the particle is to reach the origin, its kinetic energy at z=0 must be non-negative: U(z0)≥U(0).
Since U(0)=αR, this gives the single inequality
R2+z02+(β−1)z0≥R.−(1)
Let us examine each option one by one.
Case A:
β=41,z0=725R(=3.571R).
Compute
R2+z02=R1+(725)2=R49674=7674R≈3.709R,(β−1)z0=−43⋅725R=−2.678R.
Thus
R2+z02+(β−1)z0≈3.709R−2.678R=1.031R>R.
Inequality (1) is satisfied, so the particle reaches z=0.
Option A is correct.
Case B:
β=41,z0=73R(=0.4286R).R2+z02=R1+(73)2=1.088R,(β−1)z0=−43⋅73R=−0.321R.
Sum =1.088R−0.321R=0.767R<R, violating (1).
Hence the particle cannot reach the origin.
Option B is wrong.
Case C:
β=41,z0=3R(=0.577R).R2+z02=R1+31=1.155R,(β−1)z0=−43⋅0.577R=−0.433R.
Sum =1.155R−0.433R=0.722R<R, so the particle cannot reach z=0.
To see what happens, look at the force
F(z)=−dzdU=−α[R2+z2z+(β−1)].
For the given z0, evaluate the bracket:
R2+z02z0+(β−1)=21−43=−41.
Hence F(z0)=+4α, i.e. a force in the +z direction.
The particle first moves upward, its kinetic energy increases, and because the
potential U(z) grows as z→∞ (for β=41, U∼αβz),
it finally comes to rest at some z=z1 where U(z1)=U(z0), and then
returns to z0.
Thus the particle executes oscillatory motion between z0 and z1 and indeed
returns to its starting point.
Option C is correct.
Case D:
Take any β>1 and any z0>0.
Because 0<R2+z02z0<1, we get
R2+z02+(β−1)z0>R+0=R.
Inequality (1) is satisfied for every positive z0; therefore the particle
always acquires enough mechanical energy to reach the origin.
Option D is correct.
Hence the correct choices are:
Option A, Option C and Option D.
Tagged Relation between field and potential, equipotential surfaces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.