RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Relation between field and potential, equipotential surfaces

A disk of radius RR with uniform positive charge density σ\sigma is placed on the xyxy plane with its center at the origin. The Coulomb potential along the z-axis is

V(z)=σ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z)V(z) = \dfrac{\sigma}{2\epsilon_0}\left(\sqrt{R^2 + z^2} - z\right)

A particle of positive charge qq is placed initially at rest at a point on the z axis with z=z0z = z_0 and z0>0z_0 > 0. In addition to the Coulomb force, the particle experiences a vertical force F⃗=−ck^\vec{F} = -c\hat{k} with c>0c > 0. Let β=2cϵ0qσ\beta = \dfrac{2c\epsilon_0}{q\sigma}. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

SOLUTION

The electrostatic potential produced by the charged disk is given as
V(z)=σ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z).V(z)=\dfrac{\sigma}{2\epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right).

For a particle of charge qq the corresponding electrostatic potential energy is
UC(z)=qV(z)=qσ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z).U_{\text{C}}(z)=qV(z)=\dfrac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right).

The particle is also acted upon by a constant downward force F⃗=−ck^\vec F=-c\hat k. Since Fz=−dUgdz=−cF_z=-\dfrac{dU_g}{dz}=-c, the mechanical potential energy associated with this force is Ug(z)=c zU_g(z)=c\,z (we take Ug(0)=0U_g(0)=0).

Hence the total potential energy of the particle is
U(z)=UC(z)+Ug(z)=qσ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z)+c z.U(z)=U_{\text{C}}(z)+U_g(z) =\dfrac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right)+c\,z.

Put α=qσ2ϵ0,β=2cϵ0qσ=cα  (β>0).\alpha=\dfrac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_{0}},\qquad \beta=\dfrac{2c\epsilon_{0}}{q\sigma}=\dfrac{c}{\alpha} \;(\beta\gt 0). Then

U(z)=α[R2+z2−z+βz]=α[R2+z2+(β−1)z].U(z)=\alpha\Bigl[\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z+\beta z\Bigr] =\alpha\Bigl[\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}+(\beta-1)z\Bigr].

The motion is one-dimensional along the zz-axis. Because only conservative forces act, the mechanical energy E=U(z)+KE=U(z)+K is conserved. At the instant t=0t=0 the particle is released from rest at z=z0z=z_0, so E=U(z0).E=U(z_0).

If the particle is to reach the origin, its kinetic energy at z=0z=0 must be non-negative:
U(z0)≥U(0).U(z_0)\ge U(0). Since U(0)=αR,U(0)=\alpha R, this gives the single inequality

R2+z02+(β−1)z0  ≥  R.−(1)\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}+(\beta-1)z_0\;\ge\;R.\qquad -(1)

Let us examine each option one by one.

Case A:

β=14,  z0=257R  (=3.571R).\beta=\dfrac14,\; z_0=\dfrac{25}{7}R \;(=3.571R). Compute R2+z02=R1+(257)2=R67449=6747R≈3.709R,\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}=R\sqrt{1+\Bigl(\dfrac{25}{7}\Bigr)^{2}} =R\sqrt{\dfrac{674}{49}}=\dfrac{\sqrt{674}}{7}R\approx3.709R, (β−1)z0=−34⋅257R=−2.678R.(\beta-1)z_0=-\dfrac34\cdot\dfrac{25}{7}R=-2.678R. Thus R2+z02+(β−1)z0≈3.709R−2.678R=1.031R>R.\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}+(\beta-1)z_0\approx3.709R-2.678R=1.031R\gt R. Inequality (1)(1) is satisfied, so the particle reaches z=0z=0. Option A is correct.

Case B:

β=14,  z0=37R  (=0.4286R).\beta=\dfrac14,\; z_0=\dfrac{3}{7}R\;(=0.4286R). R2+z02=R1+(37)2=1.088R,\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}=R\sqrt{1+\Bigl(\dfrac{3}{7}\Bigr)^{2}} =1.088R, (β−1)z0=−34⋅37R=−0.321R.(\beta-1)z_0=-\dfrac34\cdot\dfrac{3}{7}R=-0.321R. Sum =1.088R−0.321R=0.767R<R,=1.088R-0.321R=0.767R\lt R, violating (1)(1). Hence the particle cannot reach the origin. Option B is wrong.

Case C:

β=14,  z0=R3  (=0.577R).\beta=\dfrac14,\; z_0=\dfrac{R}{\sqrt3}\;(=0.577R). R2+z02=R1+13=1.155R,\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}=R\sqrt{1+\dfrac13}=1.155R, (β−1)z0=−34⋅0.577R=−0.433R.(\beta-1)z_0=-\dfrac34\cdot0.577R=-0.433R. Sum =1.155R−0.433R=0.722R<R,=1.155R-0.433R=0.722R\lt R, so the particle cannot reach z=0z=0.

To see what happens, look at the force F(z)=−dUdz=−α[zR2+z2+(β−1)].F(z)=-\dfrac{dU}{dz} =-\alpha\left[\dfrac{z}{\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}}+(\beta-1)\right]. For the given z0z_0, evaluate the bracket: z0R2+z02+(β−1)=12−34=−14.\dfrac{z_0}{\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}}+(\beta-1)=\dfrac{1}{2}-\dfrac34=-\dfrac14. Hence F(z0)=+α4F(z_0)=+\dfrac{\alpha}{4}, i.e. a force in the +z+z direction. The particle first moves upward, its kinetic energy increases, and because the potential U(z)U(z) grows as z→∞z\to\infty (for β=14\beta=\tfrac14, U∼αβzU\sim\alpha\beta z), it finally comes to rest at some z=z1z=z_1 where U(z1)=U(z0)U(z_1)=U(z_0), and then returns to z0z_0. Thus the particle executes oscillatory motion between z0z_0 and z1z_1 and indeed returns to its starting point. Option C is correct.

Case D:

Take any β>1\beta\gt1 and any z0>0z_0\gt0. Because 0<z0R2+z02<1,0\lt\dfrac{z_0}{\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}}\lt1, we get R2+z02+(β−1)z0  >  R+0=R.\sqrt{R^{2}+z_0^{2}}+(\beta-1)z_0 \;>\;R+0=R. Inequality (1)(1) is satisfied for every positive z0z_0; therefore the particle always acquires enough mechanical energy to reach the origin. Option D is correct.

Hence the correct choices are:
Option A, Option C and Option D.

Tagged Relation between field and potential, equipotential surfaces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRelation between field and potential, equipotential surfaces
TypeMultiple correct