RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Electric flux and Gauss's law

In the figure, the inner (shaded) region A represents a sphere of radius rA=1r_A = 1, within which the electrostatic charge density varies with the radial distance rr from the center as ρA=kr\rho_A = kr, where kk is positive. In the spherical shell B of outer radius rBr_B, the electrostatic charge density varies as ρB=2kr\rho_B = \dfrac{2k}{r}. Assume that dimensions are taken care of. All physical quantities are in their SI units.

Figure for JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question on Electric flux and Gauss's law

Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

SOLUTION

The charge distribution is spherically symmetric, so we can treat every region with Gauss’s law.

1. Charge enclosed by the inner solid sphere A (rA=1r_A = 1)
Density: ρA=kr\rho_A = k r for 0≤r≤10 \le r \le 1.
QA=∫01ρA 4πr2 dr=4πk∫01r3 dr=4πk[r44]01=πk\displaystyle Q_A = \int_{0}^{1} \rho_A\,4\pi r^2 \,dr = 4\pi k\int_{0}^{1} r^3\,dr = 4\pi k\left[\frac{r^4}{4}\right]_{0}^{1}= \pi k

2. Charge enclosed in the shell B up to an outer radius rBr_B
Density: ρB=2kr\rho_B = \dfrac{2k}{r} for 1≤r≤rB1 \le r \le r_B.
QB=∫1rBρB 4πr2 dr=4π∫1rB2kr r2 dr=8πk∫1rBr dr=8πk[r22]1rB=4πk(rB2−1)\displaystyle Q_B = \int_{1}^{r_B} \rho_B\,4\pi r^2\,dr = 4\pi \int_{1}^{r_B} \frac{2k}{r}\,r^2\,dr = 8\pi k\int_{1}^{r_B} r\,dr = 8\pi k\left[\frac{r^2}{2}\right]_{1}^{r_B} = 4\pi k\bigl(r_B^2-1\bigr)

3. Total charge of the whole distribution
Qtot=QA+QB=πk+4πk(rB2−1)=πk [ 4rB2−3 ]\displaystyle Q_{\text{tot}} = Q_A + Q_B = \pi k + 4\pi k\bigl(r_B^2-1\bigr) = \pi k\,[\,4r_B^2-3\,]

4. Electric field outside the shell ( r > rB )
Outside the outer radius the entire charge behaves like a point charge at the centre:
E(r)=14πϵ0 Qtotr2,r≥rB\displaystyle E(r) = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\,\frac{Q_{\text{tot}}}{r^2}, \qquad r \ge r_B

5. Checking each option

Case A: rB=32 (≈1.225)r_B=\sqrt{\dfrac{3}{2}}\,(\approx1.225)
Qtot=πk [ 4(3/2)−3 ]=πk (6−3)=3πk≠0Q_{\text{tot}} = \pi k\,[\,4(3/2)-3\,] = \pi k\,(6-3)=3\pi k \neq 0
Field outside is not zero. Option A is false. Case B: rB=32r_B=\dfrac{3}{2}
Qtot=πk [ 4(9/4)−3 ]=πk (9−3)=6πkQ_{\text{tot}} = \pi k\,[\,4(9/4)-3\,]=\pi k\,(9-3)=6\pi k
Potential just outside B is
V(rB+)=14πϵ0 QtotrB=14πϵ0 6πk3/2=14πϵ0 (4πk)=kϵ0\displaystyle V(r_B^+) = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\, \frac{Q_{\text{tot}}}{r_B} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\, \frac{6\pi k}{3/2} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\,(4\pi k) = \frac{k}{\epsilon_0}
Matches the statement. Option B is correct. Case C: rB=2r_B=2
Qtot=πk [ 4(4)−3 ]=πk (16−3)=13πkQ_{\text{tot}} = \pi k\,[\,4(4)-3\,]=\pi k\,(16-3)=13\pi k
The option claims 15πk15\pi k, so Option C is false. Case D: rB=52r_B=\dfrac{5}{2}
Qtot=πk [ 4(25/4)−3 ]=πk (25−3)=22πkQ_{\text{tot}} = \pi k\,[\,4(25/4)-3\,]=\pi k\,(25-3)=22\pi k
Field just outside is
E(rB+)=14πϵ0 22πk(5/2)2=14πϵ0 22πk25/4=22k25ϵ0\displaystyle E(r_B^+) = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\, \frac{22\pi k}{(5/2)^2} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\,\frac{22\pi k}{25/4} = \frac{22k}{25\epsilon_0}
The option states 13πkϵ0\dfrac{13\pi k}{\epsilon_0}, so Option D is false.

Hence, the only correct statement is:

Option B which is: If rB=32r_B = \dfrac{3}{2}, then the electric potential just outside B is kϵ0\dfrac{k}{\epsilon_0}.

Tagged Electric flux and Gauss's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric flux and Gauss's law
TypeMultiple correct