RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 1+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Electric flux and Gauss's law

Six charges are placed around a regular hexagon of side length aa as shown in the figure. Five of them have charge qq, and the remaining one has charge xx. The perpendicular from each charge to the nearest hexagon side passes through the center O of the hexagon and is bisected by the side.

Figure for JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question on Electric flux and Gauss's law

Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct in SI units?

SOLUTION

Let the six charges be placed at the six vertices of a regular hexagon of side length aa. For a regular hexagon the distance of every vertex from the centre OO (the circumscribed radius) is also equal to aa. Therefore, for every charge the distance to the point OO is

r=ar = a

Denote k=14πϵ0k = \dfrac{1}{4\pi \epsilon_0} for brevity.

Electric field at OO
For a point charge the magnitude of the electric field at a distance rr is E=kqr2E = k \dfrac{q}{r^{2}} and it is directed along the line joining the charge to the point of observation.

Label the six vertices in order as 1,2,3,4,5,61,2,3,4,5,6 with vertex 1 on the positive xx-axis. Five of the charges are qq and the sixth (placed at vertex 1) is xx.

The six radial directions are separated by 60∘60^\circ. If all six charges were equal to qq the vector sum of the six fields would be zero because the six vectors form a closed regular hexagon. Hence

∑i=16Ei(q)=0\sum_{i=1}^{6} \mathbf{E}_i(q) = \mathbf{0}

When the charge at vertex 1 is changed from qq to xx, every field vector except the one coming from vertex 1 remains the same. Thus the resultant field becomes

Enet=E1(x)+∑i=26Ei(q)=E1(x)−E1(q)\mathbf{E}_{\text{net}} = \mathbf{E}_1(x) + \sum_{i=2}^{6} \mathbf{E}_i(q) = \mathbf{E}_1(x) - \mathbf{E}_1(q)

The two vectors on the right-hand side have the same line of action (the radius through vertex 1), so the net magnitude is

Enet=k ∣x−q∣a2E_{\text{net}} = k\,\dfrac{|x-q|}{a^{2}}

Special cases:
• When x=qx = q, Enet=0E_{\text{net}} = 0.
• When x=−qx = -q, Enet=k 2qa2=q2πϵ0a2E_{\text{net}} = k\,\dfrac{2q}{a^{2}} = \dfrac{q}{2\pi\epsilon_0 a^{2}}.

Option B claims the value q6πϵ0a2\dfrac{q}{6\pi\epsilon_0 a^{2}}, which differs by a factor of 13\dfrac13 and is therefore incorrect.

Electric potential at OO
The potential produced by a point charge at distance rr is V=kqrV = k \dfrac{q}{r} (scalar quantity).

With five charges equal to qq and one charge equal to xx the total potential is

Vnet=k 5q+xaV_{\text{net}} = k\,\dfrac{5q + x}{a}

Special cases:
• For x=2qx = 2q, Vnet=k 7qa=7q4πϵ0aV_{\text{net}} = k\,\dfrac{7q}{a} = \dfrac{7q}{4\pi\epsilon_0 a}.
Option C contains the extra factor 3\sqrt{3} in the denominator, so it is incorrect.
• For x=−3qx = -3q, Vnet=k 2qa=q2πϵ0aV_{\text{net}} = k\,\dfrac{2q}{a} = \dfrac{q}{2\pi\epsilon_0 a}.
Option D again has the spurious factor 3\sqrt{3} and a different numerical multiplier, hence is incorrect.

Conclusion: only the statement in Option A is correct.

Correct choice: Option A which is: When x=qx = q, the magnitude of the electric field at OO is zero.

Tagged Electric flux and Gauss's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric flux and Gauss's law
TypeMultiple correct